Echo Realty has suffered a big setback in its controversial bid to redevelop the Shady Hill Center in Shadyside.
In a ruling issued Tuesday, the Pittsburgh Zoning Board of Adjustment rejected the developer’s requests for a variance and special exception needed to build a six-story complex that would feature 230 apartments and a new Giant Eagle.
The proposed development would replace the current shopping center, which includes a larger Giant Eagle, at Penn and Shady avenues. The center would be demolished to make way for the new venture, which would include a two-level, 423-space parking garage.
As part of the project, Echo wanted to build a six-story structure up to 83 ½ feet high to hold the apartments, the new grocery and other retail. That’s much taller than the 60 feet and four stories allowed in the Urban Neighborhood Commercial zoning district where the project would be built. The special exception, if granted, would have given Echo the ability to build to 85 feet.
But in rejecting the request, the zoning board stated that among the requirements for granting such an exception are that the site can’t be within 200 feet of any residential-zoned property and that the additional height won’t create detrimental impacts involving traffic or the views from such properties.
In Echo’s case, not only is the five-acre site on which it planned to build within 200 feet of residential-zoned property but actually abuts it, the zoning board noted.
Read More
Echo had sought the variance to allow for no separation between the development site and the residential neighborhood.
During an October zoning board hearing, Echo stated, according to Tuesday’s decision, that the 230 apartment units are essential to the economic viability of the proposed redevelopment and that the proposed height arose from discussions with the community.
The arguments didn’t sway the board.
“The preference as to how to provide residential units on the site is not sufficient to justify the elimination of one of the special exception criteria for the requested additional height,” it stated.
In addition, shadow studies, renderings and other information provided at the hearing “are not sufficient to demonstrate that the site is sufficiently separated from other properties zoned residential so that the height and bulk proposed, with the impacts on service and traffic flow, will not have detrimental impacts on other affected residential property beyond the area that the applicant considered.”
Although the project had the support of East Liberty Development Inc. and the Shadyside Action Coalition, it was opposed by residents of the neighboring Village of Shadyside.
They raised concerns about the redevelopment’s impact on traffic and views from their properties in part because of the height and bulk of the proposed six-story mixed use structure.
Philip Bishop, Echo vice president, said the company was disappointed in the zoning board’s decision but still plans to move ahead with the project “in some form or fashion.”
“We intend to redevelop the property, yes,” he said.
He did not know at this point what changes, if any, would be made to the current plan.
Echo has 30 days to appeal the ruling to Allegheny County Common Pleas Court. It is still digesting the decision and can’t say yet whether it will do so, Mr. Bishop said.
Kevin McKeegan, the attorney who represented Echo at the hearing, declined to comment.
As part of its proposal, Echo had committed to making 15% of the apartments affordable to lower income residents and to providing $50,000 to help residents buy passes for public transit. It also planned to build and maintain a parklet on Aurelia Street.
Mark Belko: 412-263-1262 or mbelko@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.