The old platform from which produce wholesalers once hawked everything from lettuce to bananas is still there. So are the ancient loading docks in the back of the building.
And inside the cavernous old warehouse, one can still find remnants of the Strip District’s iconic produce terminal’s heyday.
More than a year after Chicago-based McCaffery Interests started work on a $62.6 million makeover of the Strip landmark — one interrupted by the COVID-19 pandemic — the developer is just about ready for the grand reveal.
But instead of high-fives and champagne toasts, this celebration could have a bittersweet feel about it.
“I’d love to run the biggest party the town has ever seen to show it off. How do you do that today? You can’t. I don’t mean to be moany and groany about it, it just kind of hurts,” said Dan McCaffery, CEO of McCaffery Interests.
“You feel frustrated because it’s so beautiful. It’s so ready for the people, for the excitement it could bring.”
Read More

Mr. McCaffery is pretty proud of the near-finished product. The developer has turned a vacant beat-up relic that for decades housed fruit and vegetable wholesalers into a restored gem that he hopes to fill with retail and office.
Outside, nearly all of the historic features have remained intact.
McCaffery has restored all of the 1,533-foot-long terminal’s red brick exterior — the length of five football fields.
The developer not only has kept the old concrete platform that runs the length of the facility along Smallman Street but has expanded it by another 6 feet to make it more pedestrian friendly.
Stairs, seating areas and a lower sidewalk were added with the same purpose in mind. The terminal’s old wooden doors are still being used at the back of the structure facing the Allegheny River. Windows are new but retain their historic character.
Inside, McCaffery preserved the remnants of an old office structure used by a wholesaler, leaving it to an eventual tenant to decide whether to keep that as part of the build-out. The interior has been scrubbed clean and seems to be much brighter than the dank, musty space that served wholesalers in the past.

The biggest change involves three pedestrian passageways cut through the building at 17th, 18th and 20th streets. While they break up part of the structure on the inside, they have not affected its continuous five-block length or the roof line on the outside.
Inside the brightly red-colored 17th Street passageway, produce-like crates serve as decorative fixtures for lighting.
During a tour Wednesday, Mr. McCaffery said he can’t wait to give the public a look — COVID-19 permitting. “We’re excited to show it off. We’re excited to get tenants in. We’re excited for people to get their health and freedom and all of the rest of that back soon because that’s a big part of the city.”
To get to this point, McCaffery has overcome a six-year ordeal.
That included a city-arranged shotgun wedding with another developer that ultimately failed. The pandemic not only halted construction for more than a month but wreaked havoc on retailers and restaurants, both of which McCaffery had targeted to fill the massive space.

Despite the latter challenge, the developer has been making progress in leasing space.
A Fine Wine & Good Spirits Premium Collection store operated by the Pennsylvania Liquor Control Board will be the first tenant to open its doors, probably before Thanksgiving. It will occupy 9,654 square feet of space at the terminal’s east end.
Last week, McCaffery announced leases with three additional tenants — Chicago-based brewery collective and beer hall District Brew Yard, organic garden and gift shop City Grows, of Upper Lawrenceville, and OnPar now, a female-focused golf instruction and practice facility.
With the signings, Mr. McCaffery said about 25% to 30% of the 163,500-square-foot terminal is under lease. He added he has letters of intent with tenants he declined to name for another 35%. He expects to start turning space over to the signed tenants in the next month.
Post-Gazette
Mr. McCaffery said he feels the new tenants he has signed so far are “100%” in keeping with his commitment not to compete with the eclectic mix of Penn Avenue merchants a block away who constitute the Strip’s heart and soul.
“I can’t promise a Penn Avenue merchant that he won’t have to step up the level of his service. ... That’s up to everybody who’s in business. But we’re not targeting, competing, with any particular merchant on Penn Avenue. We want both of these things to be really exciting,” he said.
While McCaffery had pledged to anchor the western end of the terminal at 16th Street with a food-centric market, those plans seem to have fizzled. Mr. McCaffery said the tenant he had for the space didn’t pan out. Now he’s looking at a “different variety of retail.”
“We might do on a temporary basis to see how it goes something like the old city market,” he said.
Nonetheless, he said he remains committed to using “commercially reasonable efforts” to lease at least 40,000 square feet of space within the terminal to local businesses. He expects to reach that goal.
“We’re going to live up to our promises,” he said.

Jim Coen, president of the Strip District Business Association and owner of the Yinzers souvenir stores on Penn Avenue, said none of the tenants that McCaffery has signed so far directly compete with other neighborhood merchants.
“If he keeps trying to stay away from things that are here, everyone can work together to make money,” he said. “As time goes on, we’re hoping the terminal building signs tenants. It’s not going anywhere, so we’d love to see it succeed.”
He stressed, though, that it could be tough to attract tenants, particularly on the restaurant and retail side, given the realities of COVID-19.
Mr. McCaffery acknowledged the pandemic is not making it easier for anybody. It’s a “tough call” for many local businesses to invest money into a new venture given the continued uncertainty surrounding the virus, he said.
But he noted he has been encouraged by the number that have expressed interest in at least discussing a possible location within the terminal.
“I feel poorly for the merchants. We are really reaching out to local people and family businesses because I believe strongly that’s what this community represents,” he said.
Across the street from the produce terminal, McCaffery also is completing a $50 million rehab of an old warehouse at 1600 Smallman St. being converted into office and retail space.
It has signed autonomous vehicle firm Aurora Innovation to take the three floors of office space. That project, like the produce terminal, has suffered setbacks, including the pandemic and a fire, both of which shut down construction.
Despite trials on both sides of Smallman, including his long struggle to secure the rights to the terminal, which is still owned by the city, Mr. McCaffery said he never thought about giving up.
“I’m Irish. C’mon,” he said with a laugh.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.