An extended-stay furnished apartment business on the 12th floor of the old Kaufmann’s/Macy’s department store in Downtown is checking out.

Churchill Living has decided to cease operations in the Kaufmann’s Grand redevelopment on Smithfield Street.

Michael Samschick, president and CEO of Philadelphia-based Core Realty, the building owner, confirmed Thursday that Churchill would be leaving its space after June 30.

The departure comes less than a month after the business ran afoul of an arrangement it had with the owner of the Even Hotel space on the fifth and sixth floors of the old department store.

Advertise with us

It represents yet another twist in the five-year saga involving the star-crossed redevelopment, which has been plagued by construction delays, lawsuits, liens and an electrical vault fire.

Last month, Florida-based Fontainebleau Development’s deal to acquire the Downtown landmark collapsed, leaving the project in limbo, although Mr. Samschick says he has an investor lined up to step into the breach.

The building at one time was one of the city’s premier shopping destinations, featuring restaurants, a bookstore, a hair salon and a famous clock where Pittsburghers often met.

Mr. Samschick said the departure of Churchill is one of the changes he is making to address issues raised by the building’s residents, who have been upset about a lack of promised amenities, dirty hallways, only one working elevator, mice infestations, lax security and other problems.

Churchill’s extended-stay operation came under scrutiny last month because it appeared to be renting 12th-floor furnished apartment units for as little as $79 a night based on a minimum three-day stay.

Advertise with us

That did not sit well with Reception Hotels and Resorts, which owns the fifth and sixth floors used by the Even Hotel.

Under a condominium agreement with Reception, Core cannot use any of its spaces for hotel purposes. Reception has said it does not mind rentals of 30 days or more but objects to anything less that.

Churchill, Mr, Samschick said, tried to make the arrangement work by leasing for 30 days or more, but found that it was not financially feasible, particularly in light of the COVID-19 pandemic that has devastated the hotel industry.

“They have tried really hard to adhere to that. Because that is not an achievable result, we have officially agreed to part ways and they will no longer be a tenant in the building,” he said.

“We’re going to release them from their obligation. We don’t want them in there if they cannot adhere to the requirements of the document.”

Advertise with us

Churchill representatives could not be reached for comment. However, a booking agent told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette that the company would no longer be in the building after June 30.

She said it was looking for other space in Pittsburgh. “This one was not suitable for our needs,” she said.

Matthew Shollar, a Reception Hotels representative, said he has no problem with Churchill being in the building as long as it can adhere to the condominium agreement.

The extended-stay operation also caught the attention of the residents who are leasing luxury apartments on other floors of the mixed-use development. Besides the other issues they have raised, residents have expressed concerns about big crowds congregating and loud parties taking place on the 12th floor.

Mr. Samschick said he is in the process of “making sweeping changes” to address all of the problems those residents have detailed as he works to finalize a deal with a new investor to become involved in the project.

Advertise with us

Core is bringing in a new general manager, a new manager and a new leasing team for the development, he said

The developer also is adding to its staff in maintenance and other areas. It has been working hand in hand with a resident representative “directly implementing and slowly putting in place the things that are important to ensuring” quality of life.

In a June 1 letter, residents requested a meeting with Mr. Samschick to address “issues of security, health and safety caused by Core Realty’s negligence and disregard” toward them.

They threatened to withhold rent and to pursue other actions if they did not get a response. Mr. Samschick has since been in touch with the residents.

Keith McGaha, who has been serving as a tenant representative, could not be reached for comment.

Advertise with us

Mr. Samschick has not identified the new investor he has lined up. He said Thursday the two sides were “in the final stages of dotting the I’s and crossing the T’s.”

“We’re very excited. We would not be implementing the protocols the new investor has requested if we did not feel comfortable that this was moving forward,” he said.

Core also has been talking to Minneapolis-based retailer Target about opening a 25,000-square-foot small format store on the first floor of the building. The store would include a pharmacy and offer groceries, apparel, home goods, and other products.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.