A month after the sale of the Westinghouse Electric headquarters, Cranberry Township and the Seneca Valley School District are still looking for answers on how the transaction was handled — and hinting that the property’s annual tax abatements worth millions of dollars could be affected if they don’t come.

As it stands, the January sale of the sprawling property could cost the two taxing bodies tens of thousands of dollars in taxes.

In a Feb. 10 letter to a representative of the seller Columbia Property Trust, Cranberry Manager Jerry Andree and Seneca Valley Superintendent Tracy Vitale stated they want a “detailed breakout for the recent real estate transaction,” as well as contact information for the new owner.

Among the answers they are seeking is why there is a discrepancy between the announced $180 million sales price and the $145.4 million price listed in the deed transfer report. The gap could cost the two local taxing bodies $175,000 each in deed transfer taxes. The state could lose $350,000.

Advertise with us

One reason the township and school district have written to Columbia Property to get details is that they still aren’t certain just who bought the property, Mr. Andree said.

“We hope this letter brings transparency,” he noted.

The Jan. 17 sale has been veiled in the kind of mystery usually reserved for an Agatha Christie novel.

In announcing the transaction, Columbia Property did not give the name of the buyer. The Jones Lang LaSalle real estate firm, which represented the seller and recruited the buyer, described the latter as an “institutional investor” but gave no other details.

The name that has emerged as the buyer is Fortress Credit Advisors LLC, which bears the same New York City address as Fortress Investment Group. Fortress Credit describes itself as a global investor specializing in undervalued and distressed properties.

Advertise with us

Fortress Credit surfaced in a $135 million mortgage document relating to the sale that was filed in the Butler County recorder of deeds office Jan. 24. Fortress Credit is listed as the principal place of business for CF Cranberry, the subsidiary created by Columbia Property to sell the Westinghouse campus.

Columbia Property sold CF Cranberry and several other subsidiaries related to the headquarters to the new owner.

Mr. Andree said the township has received no new information on the transaction in the weeks that have followed the deal announcement. Public records now available don’t explain why there is a difference between the $180 million figure and the $145.4 million recorded price, he said.

In their letter to Debbie Newmark, Columbia Property senior director, corporate compliance and transactions, Mr. Andree and Ms. Vitale noted that the owner of the Westinghouse headquarters has been receiving abatements on township, school district, and Butler County real estate taxes since 2007 as part of a strategic development area created by the state.

As part of that, the township and the district “are responsible to provide periodic certifications to the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania of the owner’s compliance with local ordinances and regulations of these two taxing jurisdictions,” the letter stated. “This certification is necessary to continue to receive the tax benefits of the strategic development area.”

Advertise with us

The letter then asks for a detailed breakout of the sale and contact information for the new owner or managers “to avoid a future issue with the tax exemption benefits afforded to this property.”

Mr. Andree said the abatements could be affected because compliance with local ordinances and regulations includes the deed transfer tax.

“It’s not that I want to get in a war with them. I just want to understand, as well as Dr. Vitale, why one number [for the sales price] was reported to the media and another number was reported to the recorder of deeds,” Mr. Andree said.

Columbia Property officials declined to comment.

At the $145.4 million price, Cranberry and the district are scheduled to receive $727,000 each in transfer taxes and the state $1.4 million. The township and the district each split 1% of the 2% tax and the state gets 1%.

Advertise with us

If the tax abatement were to be withheld, it likely would impact the new owner, Mr. Andree stated.

In 2006, officials calculated that the taxes abated amounted to about $1.3 million annually. Mr. Andree has said that figure would have increased over the years but he did not have a current number.

The tax abatements on the Westinghouse property end in 2022.

Completed in 2009, the 823,979-square-foot campus houses executive offices and research and development and support functions as well as amenities such as a bank branch, a cafeteria and tennis, basketball and volleyball courts.

Mark Belko: 412-263-1262 or mbelko@post-gazette.com.

Advertise with us

This story was updated at 3:46 p.m. Feb. 19 to reflect that Columbia Property officials declined to comment.