The Pittsburgh Penguins’ latest bid to start the redevelopment of the old Civic Arena site in the lower Hill District has hit a patch of rough ice.
Pittsburgh Urban Redevelopment Authority board members tabled a vote Thursday on actions related to the construction of the first 288 units of housing, a live music venue and a parking garage after protests by some Hill leaders and residents.
During a lengthy discussion, they raised concerns about some aspects of the latest deal and complained about not having any time to review the details. The term sheet outlining the various aspects related to the developments was not available until the meeting.
The URA board decided to hold off for at least two more weeks to give Hill residents and other stakeholders time to digest those details and the various commitments made by the Penguins and the public and to tweak some of the language.
In requesting the delay, board member R. Daniel Lavelle, a city councilman who represents the Hill, said it was the prudent thing to do. A day earlier, he had been ready to give the Penguins the go-ahead to start the projects.
“At the end of the day, it’s my job to best represent [the community]. At the point where the vast majority has said we would like a little more time to review, I thought it was appropriate to give them that time,” he said.
Read More
Kevin Acklin, the Penguins’ senior vice president, said he was “comfortable” with the latest delay, one of many that have plagued the proposed $1 billion redevelopment over the past five years.
“We want nothing more than the public to be fully comfortable with the deal that we propose to strike here,” he said. “We think it’s a good deal for the city, a good deal for the Hill District, and one that will advance development.”
The URA board was to vote on a series of preliminary approvals related to the first two developments on the 28-acre publicly owned site. One involved an $80 project to build 288 residential units near Crawford Square. The other was a $120 million music venue and 850-space parking garage.
Some aspects were tied to additional community benefits, including deeper levels of affordable housing and a retail space for minority and Hill businesses as part of the music venue and garage project.
Intergen, the minority developer hired by the team to do the residential units, also pledged to work with the city Housing Authority to secure project-based vouchers that would make 20% of apartments available to households at or below 50% of the area median income.
Previously, the Penguins had been proposing that 20% of the units would be available to households at 60-80% of the AMI, a level critics argued would essentially exclude most African Americans from leasing.
If Intergen got the vouchers, it would be eligible for a $1 million URA loan to offset the cost of affordable housing. If not, it would not get the loan.
But some of the proposed terms — coupled with what they viewed as a lack of transparency — didn’t sit well with some Hill leaders and residents who attended the meeting.
Carl Redwood, chairman of the Hill District Consensus Group, continued to push the URA and the Penguins to adhere to the Hill master plan, which calls for 30% of the units to be affordable to households at or below 50% of the AMI.
The proposed term sheet stated that if vouchers are used, units would be affordable to those at 50-60% of the AMI. But Mr. Redwood noted that vouchers typically give those at 20-30% of the AMI access to such units.
URA officials said they would correct language to reflect that.
While Marimba Milliones, president and CEO of the Hill Community Development Corporation, praised parts of the latest agreement, she said residents should have an opportunity to vet it before a vote.
“I don’t understand the rush,” she said.
Residents also should be invited into such discussions early on, to challenge the normal way of doing things, and to “get what we deserve for our community,” she added.
Some residents also wondered how some of the latest community benefits, like proposed renovations to the Ammon Rec Center in the Hill to be paid for by the Penguins, were selected. Mr. Lavelle said he made the decisions based on what he believed were community priorities.
As part of the latest deal, the Penguins would get a $3 million grant to help pay for the garage. In addition, 75% of the parking tax revenue is to be diverted for the same purpose.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.