The city of Pittsburgh and the Urban Redevelopment Authority own 170 parcels in the Hill District — sites that range from ground-floor storefronts to multi-story residential and office spaces. It’s enough real estate to make a difference in the struggling community, if development can be done right.

In July, the URA plunged in, issuing a request for qualifications for developers looking to participate in redevelopment of the Centre Avenue corridor. It’s a segment of the city that decades ago boomed with grocery stores, doctors’ offices and boutiques.

The bidding process has been set up a bit differently than most such projects by using a request for qualifications — rather than a more formal request for proposals — in an effort to diversify who can be part of the project.

“This project is unique from anything else we’ve previously done,” said URA's Interim Deputy Director Diamonte Walker.

Advertise with us

The government-driven approach to revitalizing the properties makes it different than other such projects in the area. Some observers argue that community organizations embedded in the neighborhood would be better suited to nurturing the effort and more likely to give Hill residents control of their own destiny.

URA officials point to steps they’re already taking to respond to local concerns.

“We are rolling the RFQ out with some other programs to really incorporate feedback from neighborhood groups and support small nonprofits and developers … The community has made clear how they want to be involved and the URA is working to meet that community’s plan,” said Ms. Walker.

With the request for qualifications, developers can submit a 30-page binder instead of a 500-page binder “telling us how you are going to develop this parcel and what you will do with it,” said URA real estate director Nathan Clark.

Bids are due by Oct. 22, when the URA will evaluate applicants based on their experience and financial capacity, as well as their willingness to engage the community and give Hill residents first consideration for jobs. Mr. Clark said his team will solicit feedback from the community and expects to take the first batch of proposals to the URA board for approval around January.

Advertise with us

Who takes the lead?

Eventually, Mr. Clark said, URA-owned properties on Centre Avenue will be sold to a mix of for-profit developers and nonprofits, which he said would be best considering the length of the corridor and the need for private investment.

But for now, the URA’s ownership of the majority of parcels distinguishes this project from its counterparts on East Ohio Street in the North Side and Penn Avenue between Bloomfield and Garfield.

According to Rick Swartz, executive director of the Bloomfield Garfield Corp., community development corporations (CDCs) led the revitalization of Penn Avenue in the 1990s by purchasing abandoned properties and leasing them. Mark Fatla, the president of the Northside Leadership Conference, said the nonprofit has been spearheading the revitalization of East Ohio Street by using a similar strategy.

“It’s important for nonprofits to take the lead,” Mr. Swartz said.

Advertise with us

Carl Redwood, a board member of the nonprofit Hill District Consensus Group, said soliciting residents’ input is particularly important for Centre Avenue because decades of gentrification and displacement have made Hill residents skeptical of any kind of redevelopment.

The recent closing of the Shop’n Save grocery store in the Hill demonstrates the importance of gathering community feedback. Those who fail to do so will not generate enough sales and foot traffic, Mr. Redwood said.

According to the president of the Hill Community Development Corp., Marimba Milliones, more than 300 residents earlier helped make a plan for Centre Avenue and advocated for its implementation to the URA and other community partners.

‘I want to drive’

Developers who respond to the RFQ will be reviewed through the Development Review Panel process, which includes an evaluation by a consortium of five CDCs and a vote at quarterly Hill community meetings.

Advertise with us

In fact, Ms. Walker noted, the URA released its RFQ in response to community feedback. When it had announced plans to release a request for proposals about a year and a half ago, residents concerned about gentrification opposed the idea.

Carol Hardeman, director of the Hill District Consensus Group, said she considers Centre Avenue properties government-owned, not community-owned. There are more legalities to navigate when acquiring or leasing a space from the URA than a private nonprofit property owner, Ms. Hardeman said.

Mr. Fatla of the Northside Leadership Conference added that nonprofit property owners can provide sustained support to vendors and be more flexible because they don’t have legal constraints that a government agency might.

“The community’s got to have control of what’s going on,” said Mr. Fatla. “When someone sits there and says that they will take feedback from the community, I say, ‘I don’t want to be the passenger. I want to drive, thank you.’”

Ms. Milliones said URA’s active involvement in the Centre Avenue project “requires us to examine whether we treat predominantly black communities equitably when it comes to self-determination, land use and community control or influence.”

Advertise with us

Gathering resources

Some real estate experts question whether community groups in the Hill have financial or personnel resources to purchase, renovate and lease Centre Avenue properties.

Hill House Association — a member of the Centre Avenue Steering Committee — has been selling properties this year to pay down debt.

State Rep. Jake Wheatley, D-Hill District, said in an ideal world, CDCs would take ownership of Centre Avenue properties and lease them out to private vendors. But he said Hill nonprofits lack personnel and capital to own and monitor a cluster of properties.

According to former state senator and URA board member Jim Ferlo, neighborhoods must have a strong residential community and a high percentage of homeownership to reestablish a commercial street.

Advertise with us

Mr. Clark from the URA said the parcels that the agency is soliciting developers for include some designated for residential buildings.

“You can acquire parcels and get grants to start businesses, but at the end, you need the money,” said Mr. Redwood of the Hill District Consensus Group. “The biggest challenge is making the neighborhood more economically viable and active without changing the socio-demographic composition of the neighborhood.”