They won’t drink to this — at least not yet.
Some Pittsburgh Planning Commission members ripped a proposal Tuesday to raze the old Froggy’s restaurant and several other buildings on Market Street and First Avenue Downtown to clear the way for a massive redevelopment that would include a “signature tower.”
During a briefing, several members urged developer Troiani Properties to reconsider the fate of structures in advance of a hearing and a vote next month on the plan to demolish them.
Member Sabina Deitrick said demolitions would gut the section of Market Street that is part of the Firstside Historic District listed on the National Register of Historic Places. “This project destroys it,” she said. “It destroys the feel of it and what the history is.”
She added it would be “hard to call it a Firstside Historic District after taking these buildings down.”
Troiani wants to demolish the buildings to assemble a large parcel of land for a new development — one that would include a mid-rise structure facing the Boulevard of the Allies that could be anywhere from 200,000 to 290,000 square feet in size and up to 22 stories tall.
Read More
The development would include the old Froggy’s site at 100-102 Market, two others at 104 and 106-108 Market, another at 209 First Ave. It would also include the former Tramps and Papa J’s Centro properties at 212 and 214 Blvd. of the Allies, which already have been razed after planning commission approval early this year.
As currently envisioned, the office component on the boulevard would be supplemented by a mixed-use residential development at First and Market that could be anywhere from three to 10 floors high with brick facades.
Michael Troiani, a spokesman for Troiani Properties, has said the buildings on Market and First, including Froggy’s, have deteriorated to the point that they are not worth saving.
Representatives told the commission that Froggy’s, a popular nightspot that hosted the likes of Mario Lemieux and actor Jack Nicholson before closing in 2003, suffered significant water damage in the years before the Troianis bought it.
Another building has undergone a series of renovations over the years and now faces significant deterioration, making it unsafe. The building at 209 First has been vacant for 50 years with an interior that “has very little integrity.”
Clifford Levine, Troiani Properties attorney and former planning commission member, said trying to incorporate the decaying structures into the new development not only would be challenging but could lead to “awkward” architecture.
Christine Mondor, planning commission chairwoman, said it’s worth a shot.
The commission, she said, has seen “some amazing and beautiful plans” for redevelopments on Penn Avenue Downtown making use of old buildings.
She noted that some of the Market and First structures date back as far as 1872. Tearing them down would disrupt the way the blocks are situated within the historic district, resulting in a “significant change” to its character.
“I feel like you’re sitting on something that could be an asset to your market. I’m not sure you would want another thing that’s scaled to PPG Plaza,” she said, referring to the nearby office complex.
“This is a threshold into Firstside. They’re really interesting structures. I just feel like there’s probably some benefit to your project to retain and to try to work around those.”
She encouraged Troiani Properties to try harder to preserve the properties before returning to the commission.
“I feel like these structures in this location in particular require that kind of examination before I feel comfortable voting for demolition,” she said.
Mr. Troiani said afterward that he would consider the commission’s requests. He stressed the developer had looked at possible alternatives in the past and has “not found a way to reuse the structures in an economically feasible way. But I’m open to suggestions.”
Troiani Properties plans to present more detailed information about the proposed development when it returns in September, one that likely would be in compliance with the current zoning. The new development would feature brick facades at Market and First that would be comparable to the current heights, he said.
“The idea is to be reverent,” Mr. Troiani said.
Ms. Mondor argued that the fact Troiani Properties is trying to emulate the scale and nature of the buildings currently there acknowledges their importance.
Should Troiani proceed with its plan to demolish the buildings, it also could be facing a fight from local preservationists.
Matthew Falcone, president of Preservation Pittsburgh, said the group could file for a city historic designation for the structures to prevent demolition, depending on what happens before the planning commission.
While the Firstside Historic District designation can be helpful to property owners in some ways, such as in securing tax credits, it does not prevent buildings from being demolished.
Mr. Falcone believes the properties can be reused. “Despite what they’re saying that they’re obsolete and ready to fall down, I’ve seen a lot worse,” he said.
Likewise, Pittsburgh History & Landmarks Foundation, which has been talking to Troiani about incorporating the buildings into the redevelopment, is “absolutely opposed” to demolition at this point, said Karamagi Rujumba, director, development and communications.
“We want to see a consideration of all options. We fundamentally don’t believe the argument that these buildings are beyond saving,” he said.
“We have seen restoration of buildings in this state and even worse, as we did in Market Square.”
Mr. Troiani believes that some of the opponents are blinded by nostalgia. “Nobody knows what Froggy’s was before it was a bar,” he said. “It’s an idea that’s nostalgic. It’s not a place.”
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.