As the former Tramps restaurant Downtown comes down, the fate of another famous old nightspot hangs in the balance while the owner ponders a “marquee” office and residential development at the site.
Five months after the Pittsburgh Planning Commission gave the go-ahead, demolition has started on two buildings at 212 and 214 Boulevard of the Allies that once housed the Tramps and Papa J’s Centro restaurants. The latter closed in 2013.
The next to come down could be a collection of buildings on Market Street, including one that housed Froggy’s restaurant, which many viewed as among the city’s hippest nightspots before its closing in 2003.
“At that site, I truly believe the right thing to do is to raze them,” said Michael Troiani, a representative of the family that owns the buildings.
Between the buildings being demolished on the boulevard and those on Market Street, the family is hoping to assemble the land needed for what Mr. Troiani has described as a “signature tower.”
The concept involves an office structure on the Boulevard of the Allies that could be anywhere from 200,000 to 290,000 square feet in size and up to 22 stories tall.
Read More
That’s shorter than the tallest structure at nearby PPG Place, which rises 40 stories.
It would be supplemented by a residential section of anywhere from three to 10 floors at First Avenue and Market with a brick facade in a bid to keep the look in context with other buildings in that area.
The goal is to “carry the power of Market Street across the boulevard,” said Ken Doyno, principal at Rothschild Doyno Collaborative, the architect for the project. “We want to keep that energy continuing into Firstside and the boulevard.”
As part of the project, there are also plans for “supportive” retail at street level and green space.
“This is really a marquee property for us,” Mr. Troiani said Wednesday. “Our goal is to maximize the use and to [develop] something we want to put our name on and be proud of for years to come.”
The Troianis already have filed applications with the planning commission to demolish the old Froggy’s building and two others on Market, although no action has been taken to date on either. Mr. Doyno hopes to get the family’s proposal for the sites before the panel this fall.
Before the Troianis could tear down the structures, they would have to get approval of commission members, some of whom expressed uneasiness during meetings on the Tramps demolition in January.
The Market Street properties and the Tramps site on the boulevard are part of or border the Firstside Historic District listed on the National Register of Historic Places. However, that honor doesn’t afford them protection from razing.
Family members also may face challenges from preservationists, including the Pittsburgh History & Landmarks Foundation.
The foundation believes the Market Street structures could be reused, just as it preserved several in Market Square now used for a grocery, clothing and shoe stores, and apartments.
Arthur Ziegler, PHLF president, said Wednesday he and other foundation officials hope to meet with Mr. Troiani at the Froggy’s and other Market Street buildings to “get an earnest look at them” to see if they can be salvaged or reused.
“We’re all going to talk. That’s all I can tell you. We don’t know where it’s going to go,” he said.
The foundation, he said, plans to keep an open mind. It will first look to see if the buildings can be saved and at what cost. If that is not feasible, it then will try to determine if parts can be reused.
Only if neither is possible would the foundation consider a new project, Mr. Ziegler said. But it would have to be one that is marketable, can attract financing, and features a design “of great significance.”
The foundation did not stand in the way of the Tramps demolition, which Mr. Ziegler described as “very sad.”
“We’re not agreeing to any other demolitions until we all can do good objective studies,” he said.
Mr. Troiani said he is more than willing to meet with Mr. Ziegler. “I value and respect Arthur tremendously. I will speak plainly to him. Every site and situation is unique,” he said.
His family, he added, has spent 25 years collecting the properties it now wants to develop “for greater and higher uses.” Froggy’s, he said, “was destroyed when we got it.” The family has repaired the floor and roof, and stabilized beams.
“We tried to save those buildings and they’re just not marketable,” he said.
Beyond the Market Street and boulevard development, the Troianis are considering a residential project in a parking lot at First Avenue and Wood Street in the heart of the Point Park University campus that would involve apartments at the lower levels and condos above.
Mr. Troiani said razing of the properties at 212 and 214 Boulevard of the Allies is being done both by hand and machine.
Construction Junction removed wainscoting and other salvageable materials, he said. Mr. Troiani himself has saved some stone pieces and window lintels.
The structures, said to be on the verge of collapse, had a colorful history, one that reportedly included a stop on the Underground Railroad, followed by a second life as a brothel and a third as a restaurant — first Tramps and then Papa J’s.
“It’s very bittersweet,” Mr. Troiani said. “There’s some great promise of opportunity in the future, but it is a loss.”
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.