One was a former brothel and restaurant. Another was one of the hippest nightspots Downtown frequented by the likes of Mario Lemieux, Howard Cosell and Jack Nicholson. Both could be facing the wrecking ball.
Representatives of the Troiani family pitched a proposal to the city planning commission Tuesday to demolish two 19th-century buildings at 212 and 214 Boulevard of the Allies that once housed Tramps and the Papa J’s Centro restaurants.
The demolitions are part of a broader plan that includes the razing of the old Froggy’s restaurant and bar on Market Street and two adjacent buildings in a bid to assemble a large tract of land for future development. The Troianis own all of the parcels.
Together, the properties present “tremendous opportunities to increase the vibrancy, to increase the tax base, to move to higher and better uses” in that part of Downtown, said Ken Doyno, principal at Rothschild Doyno Collaborative, architect for the project.
But parts of the proposal could face opposition from two of the city’s top preservation groups — the Pittsburgh History and Landmarks Foundation and Preservation Pittsburgh.
Arthur Ziegler, PHLF president, said the foundation won’t stand in the way of the demolition of the two Boulevard of the Allies buildings. But that is not the case with those on Market, which the foundation would like to see preserved.
Read More
“The buildings on Market, we feel, are very important,” Mr. Ziegler said.
Preservation Pittsburgh has yet to take a formal position on the proposal. But it, too, has concerns about so many buildings being razed in a block bordered by Market, First Avenue and Boulevard of the Allies.
The buildings are part of or border the Firstside Historic District, which is listed on the National Register of Historic Places.
Matthew Falcone, Preservation Pittsburgh president, said taking down all of the buildings “seems like a pretty drastic step.” The group plans to meet with representatives of the Troiani family to discuss the proposal.
“We have a lot of concerns about taking out an entire block in a national historic district,” he said.
The current proposal before the planning commission involves only the demolition of 212 and 214 Boulevard of the Allies — two buildings with a colorful history, one that reportedly included a stop on the Underground Railroad, followed by a second life as brothel.
A restaurant called Tramps later paid homage to that second life. In 1994, Tramps became Papa J’s Centro, which closed in 2013.
The buildings have been vacant since and are now “vulnerable and physically tenuous,” Mr. Doyno said.
“This building will fall down one way or the other,” Michael Troiani added. “We can do it in a controlled way or it happens on its own.”
In the past, the Troianis have taken steps to stabilize the Market Street properties, which also are vacant. Froggy’s, owned by the late Steve “Froggy” Morris, closed in 2003 after a run of more than two decades as a premier city nightspot, one known for its stiff drinks and star-studded crowds.
But the Troianis believe demolishing the structures to create a much larger development parcel is a better option than trying to reuse vacant and narrow buildings of varying sizes, all in a declining state.
“The existing property configuration is obsolete for the marketplace and the conditions and opportunities for the marketplace,” Mr. Doyno said.
Troiani family members have yet to develop specific plans for a possible redevelopment, which also could involve adjacent surface parking lots they own.
Mr. Troiani said the goal is to provide “integrated community development” in consultation with the city and other stakeholders.
“If the community wants to see flower shops, you’re going to see a row of flower shops. If the community wants to see housing, you’re going to see a priority with housing,” he said.
He doesn’t believe the buildings are worth saving. The floors in the former Froggy’s building, for example, are buckling because of moisture damage.
“You can save anything if you will yourself to it. But I think it would be a detriment to the ultimate use of this,” Mr. Troiani said.
“This has been a generational effort to piece this all together to create an economic circumstance that’s most gainful for the city, that causes the most life, and which helps activate the whole area.”
But Mr. Ziegler believes there is potential to reuse the buildings to do a similar redevelopment to what the foundation did on the other side of Market bordering Market Square and Fifth. There, it rehabbed several buildings and brought in a grocery, a men’s shoe store, a men’s clothing store and upper floor apartments.
“We certainly want it to be looked at and see what can be done,” he said, adding he would like to work with the Troianis to develop a vision that includes preservation.
In their questioning and comments, commission members seemed to be more amenable to the demolition of the two Boulevard of the Allies buildings than the broader plan.
Chairwoman Christine Mondor said she had “serious concerns” about the potential razing of the Market Street properties given that they are located in a national historic district.
Some members also wanted to see more defined plans for the type of redevelopment that would replace the buildings.
Nonetheless, should the Froggy’s site end up being razed, Mr. Troiani suggested one way to remember it.
“Every drink of alcohol ever poured in any facility on that site should be twice as big as normal,” he said. “I think that would be honoring the life that’s taken place at that site.”
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.