The region offered Amazon as much as $9.7 billion in incentives, free land and even its own designated space at Pittsburgh International Airport as part of the losing bid for the company’s second headquarters.

It even proposed zipping Amazon employees to the airport on a new rapid transit line.

After fighting for more than a year to keep the bid secret, Pittsburgh and Allegheny County released the details Thursday, two days after Amazon divided HQ2 between New York and Arlington, Va.

By one estimate, the package totaled $9.7 billion. But city and county officials claimed that estimate was based on Amazon bringing all 50,000 jobs and $5 billion in investment promised to Pittsburgh on day one.

Advertise with us

Sites offered to Amazon in Pittsburgh

Five primary sites Amazon toured during its early April visit to Pittsburgh:

They valued the incentives at $4 billion, based on gradual investment and employment by Amazon over 10 years.

The $9.7 billion also included up to $4.6 billion in incentives the state offered Amazon, while the $4 billion number reflects only $1.38 billion of the state money, again based on a gradual rather than immediate build-out.

Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto and Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald said the various incentives would have required approval from city and county councils and the city school board.

Advertise with us

At least one Pittsburgh school board member didn’t like a letter included as part of the package that seemed to commit the district to some of the incentives promised to Amazon.

Kevin Carter, chair of the school board’s business and finance committee, whose signature was on the letter, said he did not recall signing it.

He noted, as did school solicitor Ira Weiss, that any offer of tax increment financing or other incentives would have required a vote by the full board. Mr. Carter said he did not know what the region was proposing until Thursday.

“Let me be clear . . . I had never seen the Amazon proposal and was not aware of any promises made by PPS to approve tax incentives for the retail giant. I find this part of the proposal most disturbing as a PPS Board Member,” Mr. Carter wrote in a Facebook post.

“The only thing we gave them was a very vanilla letter that we would cooperate in their effort. There was no specific commitment,” Mr. Weiss added.

Advertise with us

“I don’t know how they came up with these assumptions. This thing was done in the most secretive opaque fashion I can imagine.”

Mayor Peduto releases details of Amazon HQ2 bid

The city and the county sent similar letters. City Council President Bruce Kraus, who signed the city’s letter along with Mr. Peduto, said the offers were contingent on council’s approval.

There’s no question the region’s proposal represented big numbers. It was on par with the $8.5 billion dangled by Maryland and the $7 billion by New Jersey. New York and Arlington combined offered about $3.8 billion in incentives in exchange for getting 25,000 jobs and $2.5 billion in investment, or half of what Amazon originally planned.

The key piece of the local investment totaled $2.1 billion.

At a press conference Thursday, Mr. Peduto and Mr. Fitzgerald said that money would have been generated mainly through taxes on Amazon employees. According to the proposal, those taxes included sales, local income, payroll preparation, and local service levies.

Advertise with us

None of the funding would have gone directly to Amazon and no existing tax revenues would have been used, the city and county political leaders said.

Instead, the $2.1 billion would have been earmarked to address needs such as affordable housing, transportation with a possible light rail extension, workforce development, and infrastructure, including new water lines.

Those investments would have benefited the region, helped prepare local residents for Amazon jobs, and kept housing affordable in the face of such massive development, Mr. Peduto said.

“The issue of it was just going into [Amazon CEO] Jeff Bezos’ pocket is not a fair or valid argument,” he maintained.

“[The $2.1 billion] would have gone back to the major issues that we have within the city and this region and funded those initiatives to be able to make the benefit for all and, in particular, for those of lower income within this city and region.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Fitzgerald estimated that Amazon’s presence would have generated $5.8 billion in tax revenue, with $3.7 billion of that going to the city, county and schools.

Local leaders may have issued bonds to get some of the $2.1 billion upfront and would have asked Amazon to guarantee the debt payments.

The $2.1 billion figure didn’t include, depending on the way it was calculated, another $556 million to $938 million in tax increment and similar transit-oriented financing, plus parking tax diversions, potentially available to Amazon.

The online retailer could have used those tools for infrastructure upgrades and site preparation and upfront costs.

Beyond the money, the proposal included an offer of free land depending on where Amazon decided to settle, with the state incentives being used to reimburse the property owners.

Advertise with us

The five primary sites presented to the e-commerce giant were the 178-acre Hazelwood Green in Hazelwood, the 28-acre former Civic Arena land, Carrie Furnace in Rankin and Swissvale, the airport’s World Trade Center, and the Strip District, believed to be Amazon’s favorite.

At Hazelwood Green, site of the old LTV Coke Works, the assemblage included a 5.3-acre parcel owned by the Regional Industrial Development Corp. next to its Mill 19 redevelopment.

In the Strip, a consortium of public and private owners led by Oxford Development Co., the developer behind the 3 Crossings complex, was prepared to offer Amazon up to 8 million square feet of space near the Allegheny riverfront.

On an interim basis, as much as 600,000 square feet of space was available at 525 William Penn Place, Downtown, according to the proposal. It also stated that Faros Properties, owner of Nova Place, the former Allegheny Center on the North Side, had committed to holding 500,000 square feet of space for Amazon.

Beyond free land, there were other potential perks for Amazon — including its own business-class, high-speed transit connection between HQ2, Downtown and the airport.

Advertise with us

According to the proposal, the region planned to utilize the West Busway and “shoulder-running transit options” to provide “reliable, traffic-free access to the airport.”

Amie Downs, Mr. Fitzgerald’s spokeswoman, said she had no other details. “This was merely a proposal. Details would have been worked out when negotiations began, if this was something that was pursued,” she said.

Mr. Fitzgerald said any such amenities would have been available to all, not just Amazon.

As part of the airport’s upcoming $1.1 billion modernization, regional leaders also offered Amazon “the opportunity to design a space suited to its needs, such as a terminal dedicated to shipping logistics or other uses.”

Airport spokesman Bob Kerlik said that could have included a hangar or cargo facility with direct access to a runway.

Advertise with us

But the offer of big incentives and other perks wasn’t what Amazon focused on during a quick briefing with local leaders after Tuesday’s decision.

Mr. Fitzgerald said the selection ultimately came down to the fact that Pittsburgh just wasn’t big enough.

“I think the biggest thing was size. The biggest thing was impact,” he said.

Amazon did not specify any negatives about the region, instead focusing on positives such as universities and the talent they are producing, the low cost of living and housing, and opportunities available for young people.

“It was sort of like that conversation you have when breaking up — it’s not you, it’s me,” Mr. Peduto said. “They could not have been more complimentary toward Pittsburgh and southwestern Pennsylvania.

Advertise with us

Here is the bid.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262. 

This story was updated at 1:21 p.m. Nov. 16 to further clarify the incentives.