Pittsburgh and Allegheny County spent more than a month putting together their bid for Amazon’s second headquarters, identifying real estate and crafting incentives. They have even fought in court to keep the details secret, so as not to tip off competitors.

County Executive Rich Fitzgerald visited Seattle in a quest to find an edge. More than 400 stakeholders collaborated in the bidding effort and a new entity — PGHQ2 — was formed to lead the charge for HQ2.

Was it all an exercise in futility?

That’s what some cities are left to wonder after the New York Times and the Wall Street Journal reported that Amazon planned to divide HQ2 between two cities, with the Times identifying the likely locations as Long Island City, a neighborhood in Queens, and Crystal City, Va., near Washington, D.C.

Advertise with us

For the record, Amazon has not confirmed any of the reports, and one of the online retailer’s executives has even taken to Twitter to criticize leaks that Crystal City was the likely winner. The E-commerce behemoth is believed to be talking to multiple communities, with Dallas being one of the others identified in press reports.

Amazon already has a big presence in both New York and Washington, so it could be seen as a no-brainer if the new headquarters is split between them. The Times said Amazon has more employees in Crystal City and Long Island than any other place outside of its Seattle home and the Bay Area of California.

But it has led some critics to question Amazon’s motive in requesting proposals last year from cities interested in bidding on HQ2, with its promise of up to 50,000 jobs and $5 billion in investment over 17 years.

The process drew bids from 238 locations, with those narrowed to 20, including Pittsburgh, in January.

“It seems very likely that this outcome was preordained and that this whole process has served the particular aims of Amazon and has done so at the expense of cities and their time and energy,” said Stacy Mitchell, co-director of the Institute for Local Self Reliance, a  non-profit research group with offices in Minneapolis, Portland, Me., and Washington, D.C., that focuses on reducing corporate concentration and expanding economic opportunity.

Advertise with us

Michael Farren, research fellow with the Mercatus Center at George Mason University who has written about Amazon’s economic impact and the dangers of subsidizing it, said in most competitions involving big economic deals, companies have a short list of targets from the very start.

“I think cities that thought they had a chance [at HQ2] are right to think it was an exercise in futility. I don’t think there was ever a big possibility that Amazon was going to locate in a mid-sized city because you’re talking about potentially employing 50,000 people,” he said.

Only the largest of metropolitan areas could handle that kind of influx or attract the kind of talent needed for such an operation, Mr. Farren noted.

“So the open competition encouraged a lot more cities to apply than actually had a good chance of winning. But I think a lot of cities knew that from the beginning,” he said.

Even if the reports about Crystal City and Long Island City prove to be true, other HQ2 bidders have no reason to feel shorted, said Thomas Stringer, a managing director at professional services firm BDO’s New York office

Advertise with us

He pointed out that it was the cities themselves that chose to participate.

“I have no reason to believe that Amazon was not 100 percent open in saying this was what we wanted to shoot for, this is what we need,” he said.

Mr. Stringer added he was not surprised about reports that Amazon may evenly divide HQ2 — or is it now HQ2 and HQ3?. He said there were concerns from the start about any city being able to handle such impact.

“That was a very aspirational [request for proposals],” he said. “This might reflect some of the realities of that if it turns out to be true.”

Even at 25,000 people, a split Amazon HQ2 still would employ more people than the headquarters of many other big companies.

Advertise with us

And some of bidders that weren’t selected among the 20 finalists might still get work. Amazon says it has announced 6,000 new jobs in some of those cities.

Where Amazon HQ2, split or not, ends up depends in part on what it “values as their priorities,” Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto said Monday. He was not available for comment Wednesday. Mr. Fitzgerald could not be reached for comment.

Phil Cynar, spokesman for PGHQ2, the Allegheny Conference on Community Development subsidiary handling the region’s HQ2 bid, declined to comment, saying there would be time to talk about issues involving the process once Amazon announces its decision.

But John Valentine, executive director of the Pittsburgh Downtown Community Development Corp., does not believe the region’s efforts were a waste of time even if HQ2 goes elsewhere.

“If I was a government official, I would have done the exact same thing. You had to pursue it. You’re looking at 50,000 jobs in a region that lost a lot of jobs in the last few decades,” he said. “I would have tried everything I could to get it.”

Advertise with us

Whatever the outcome, one thing is certain — Amazon has gathered a trove of information on more than 200 locations it can use in the future in negotiating for fulfillment centers or other facilities.

“By dangling this very appealing carrot, Amazon has been able to test exactly what cities might be willing to put on the table. Whenever Amazon bargains in the future, it’s going to have a built-in advantage,” Ms. Mitchell said.

“It’s going to come to the bargaining table with this advantage over the city because it knows something about what are the outer limits of what they’re willing to do.”

It’s also information that Amazon’s competitors don’t have, giving the online retailer an advantage over them. “It allows Amazon to further their monopoly ambitions,” Ms. Mitchell maintained.

While questioning whether some of the smaller finalists ever had a shot at HQ2, Mr. Farren said the decision, if it has been made, to split the headquarters makes sense in terms of access to talent.

Advertise with us

And if nothing else, with all the data Amazon has gathered, “they could open their own site selection consulting business,” he joked.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.