The Howard Hanna real estate company has been expanding so rapidly into markets outside of the Pittsburgh region in recent years that members of the Hanna family did not always have time to inspect the buildings that came with the companies they acquired.

“We bought a company in the last seven or eight years and we didn’t realize the offices were in as crappy a shape as they were,” said Howard “Hoddy” Hanna III, chairman of O’Hara-based Howard Hanna Holdings Inc. “So, unfortunately we had to spend a lot more initial money fixing and remodeling the branch locations than we would have liked to.”

That experience forced the family to put a new policy in place — to physically inspect every office building before closing on any acquisitions.

The timing of the error could have been a blessing in disguise. The pace of mergers and acquisitions for the brokerage would increase a short time later. In early 2013, the family and the company’s lenders established a $250 million line of credit for acquisitions, with the goal of doubling the size of the business over three years.

Advertise with us

“We wanted to double the size of the company,” said Mr. Hanna, 71. “That was the catapult to do it, and we certainly have done it.”

At this point, the $250 million war chest has been spent. Mr. Hanna said the deals the company has made in the past five years have exceeded the loan amount.

A consolidating industry

The family-owned real estate business that began with a single office and one agent in Shadyside in 1957 has grown to 326 branch offices with 11,370 employees among nine states as far flung as Michigan, New York, Ohio and the Carolinas.

The real estate company founded by Howard Hanna Jr. with what family lore recalls as an initial investment of $40 earned a combined revenue of $812.5 million in 2017 from the 18 individual companies now under the banner of Howard Hanna Holdings, according to the firm.

Advertise with us

Howard Hanna is one of several real estate companies nationally using the strategy of growing by acquisitions in key markets. Mergers and acquisitions activity among all kinds of real estate firms hit $524.7 billion last year — nearly 25 percent more than the 2007 record of $424.5 billion, according to figures from Thompson Reuters.

Washington, D.C., real estate powerhouse Long & Foster was acquired last year by HomeServices of America, an affiliate of Berkshire Hathaway, the conglomerate owned by billionaire investor Warren Buffet. After that deal, Mr. Buffet told investors that HomeServices is likely to continue to the hunt.

For small- to mid-sized real estate brokers, merging can offer a path to survival. Operational costs are rising and there’s growing competition from tech companies that have empowered buyers to search for their own properties.

“A lot of small- to medium-sized brokers are having trouble staying profitable and acquisition could be their only way out,” said Scott Wright, director of mergers and acquisitions at Real Trends, a Castle Rock, Colorado-based consulting firm.

He said profit margins are under pressure because brokers are being forced to pay a higher cut of real estate sales commissions to keep and attract good agents.

Advertise with us

Brokers also are getting squeezed by market disruptors such as Compass, a startup that is reshaping the home buying experience with the use of technology, such as glowing “for sale” signs that agents can control with their smartphones; iBuying companies that will make sellers an offer on their home within minutes, or days, sight unseen; and flat-fee real estate agents that have come onto the scene in recent years.

An exit plan

There is a big group of independent owners of real estate brokerages who have reached their late 60s and 70s. All of their wealth is tied up in the business and they want to cash out.

For them, getting acquired is an exit plan.

“Usually almost every major deal that we’ve done has been because the owners did not have a succession plan,” Hoddy Hanna said. “They had all this money tied up in paper in this business and they wanted to do something else, be it philanthropy, or go away on a boat.”

Advertise with us

That’s one thing the Hanna family won’t have to worry about. There are 10 members of the family running the business from offices in Pittsburgh, Ohio and Virginia.

At age 98, Howard Hanna Jr., the company’s founder, is no longer active in the company but he still sends a handwritten personal note to every new agent.

His wife, Anne Freyvogel Hanna, died in 2005. Their three children, Howard “Hoddy” Hanna III, Helen Hanna Casey and Annie Hanna Cestra are in charge of the business and several of the next generation fill key management roles.

The rules of expansion

In the early years of the push to expand, the Hanna family made some decisions that didn’t always make good business sense. Like that time in 1983 when they opened an office in Naples, Fla., called Cannon Real Estate — mainly because Mr. and Mrs. Hanna owned a house there.

Advertise with us

“But that was too far away. So, in 1989, we sold that company,” said Hoddy Hanna.

Then they looked closer to home. “Within six months we bought a company in New Castle and we bought a company in Youngstown,” he said.

“My mother couldn’t understand why we would trade Naples for Youngstown and New Castle ... We weren’t big enough to put enough people down there to manage it the way we wanted to manage it.”

After pulling out of Naples, the family agreed on a growth plan that would create a method to the madness of expansion. They would saturate the Pittsburgh market with the Howard Hanna brand and expand outward.

“In the mid-1980s, we decided we wanted to be a big company,” said Helen Hanna Casey, CEO of Howard Hanna Real Estate Services.

Advertise with us

As the Hannas bought real estate companies, they also acquired mortgage companies and title companies while growing their property and casualty insurance company. They started a service called Relocation Horizons, which buys the homes of corporate executives who must move.

It was a recessionary time in the housing industry because of high interest rates, Hoddy Hanna recalled. “So, we started to say for our own destiny we have to create our own mortgage products to make sure to make sure we have mortgages for people, because without mortgage money we’re not going to sell any houses.”

When the Hannas acquire a company, they typically purchase 100 percent of its stock. But every deal is different.

When Howard Hanna purchased an ownership stake in September in Allen Tate, the largest real estate company in the Carolinas, the Hannas added 47 more offices and 2,100 employees in North and South Carolina.

“There are people at the Allen Tate company who did not want to sell all their investment. So we acquired in that case, 60 percent of the ownership,” Hoddy Hanna said.

Advertise with us

Another tool has been offering franchises for sale in areas such as Morgantown, W.Va. The franchise owners pay Howard Hanna a royalty fee based on sales.

“We have 40 of those and they are primarily in cities where we don’t see ourselves in those markets for the next 10 years,” Hoddy Hanna said.

At this point, the Pittsburgh market isn’t the company’s biggest.

As of 2017, Howard Hanna closed more residential and commercial real estate deals in Cleveland [29,001 sales] than it did in Pittsburgh and Western Pennsylvania [14,481 sales]; and it sold more real estate in the state of New York [35,551 sales] than in Pennsylvania [20,766].

The D.C. problem

Advertise with us

The theory of concentric circles has worked well for Howard Hanna’s growth. Except for that empty space between northern Maryland and southeast Virginia.

“I would say that we are very interested in the Baltimore and Washington, D.C., market right now,” Hoddy Hanna said. “There’s a gap in Richmond, Baltimore and Washington, D.C. We have nothing going on in those three markets right now.”

The challenge in every new market is tied to its strategy of buying either the No. 1 or No. 2 player.

Long and Foster is the No. 1 real estate company in the Washington, D.C., area. The No. 2 broker is a very distant second.

Howard Hanna dealt with that issue when it entered Ohio -— buying the No. 2-ranked Smythe Cramer in 2003 and then, over the next two years, buying six smaller companies. It rolled them into Smythe Cramer and renamed the combined companies Howard Hanna Smyth Cramer.

Advertise with us

In New York, the Hannas pulled a similar maneuver. They bought the No. 3 home seller in state, Nothnagle, and a year later acquired Realty USA, the No. 1 real estate broker.

They are still studying how to break into that Washington-area market. Maybe roll four or five companies up together?

Hoddy Hanna is thinking about it. “But it’s tough. It’s more difficult.”

Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591.