A Cleveland developer unveiled big plans Tuesday for another former department store Downtown — offices, apartments and a raft of new restaurants.
Stark Enterprises pitched its $63 million proposal to redevelop the former Frank & Seder department store during a briefing before the city planning commission.
It plans to convert the vacant seven-story building on Smithfield Street bordering Fifth and Forbes avenues into 25,000 square feet of street-level retail, three floors of offices, and 40 apartments on the top two floors.
While some details had leaked earlier this year, the presentation Tuesday was the first time that the developer had officially cast its vision for the site.
Dubbed the Icon on Smithfield, the 286,000-square-foot mixed-use development sits across the street from the former Kaufmann’s/Macy’s department store — the one that has the famous clock and that also is undergoing redevelopment.
On the retail side, the Icon on Smithfield will be anchored by Davio’s, a Boston-based northern Italian steakhouse expected to take 9,730 square feet on the Fifth Avenue side of the building.
Read More
A revised floor plan for the retail space shows three other eateries. One is Barrio, a Cleveland-based gourmet taco restaurant that also advertises a vast selection of tequila, whiskey and beer.
Another is Taza, a Lebanese restaurant also based in Cleveland, and the third is Balance Grille, which bills itself as an Asian-Fusion restaurant. Based in the Toledo area, it serves bowls, tacos, “snacks” like potato salad, nachos, citrus brussels, creamy wontons, and swiss beets, as well as a variety of teas.
Steve Coven, Stark vice president of development, declined comment when asked about Barrio, Taza, and Balance Grille.
He did say that Stark does have commitments in place for the first-floor retail and that all 25,000 square feet “are spoken for.” That includes some traditional retail, he said.
Two retail establishments that had been on a previous floor plan — Punch Bowl Social, an entertainment and dining venue, and Honeygrow, a fast casual stir-fry restaurant with a location in East Liberty — are not on the latest one.
Mr. Coven declined to comment on the status of those.
He did confirm that Davio’s will be opening its first location in Pittsburgh and its third in Pennsylvania at the site. It will be the latest in a long line of steakhouses to open in and near Downtown.
Another, Del Frisco’s Double Eagle Steakhouse, is scheduled to open in the nearby Union Trust Building next year. Downtown lost a steakhouse recently when Red the Steakhouse located in U.S. Steel Tower closed in September after being open less than a year.
The Icon on Smithfield will be located across the street from Kaufmann’s Grand, the redeveloped former Kaufmann’s/Macy’s department store featuring 311 luxury apartments, a 160-room Even Hotel, and 130,000 square feet of retail space.
Waffles, INCaffeinated recently became the first tenant to debut in that building. The apartments and hotel have yet to open.
Mr. Coven said he did not see the two old department store sites clashing with one another.
“I don’t think it’s a competition issue. We only have 40 apartments. We’re larger unit sizes. We don’t have hundreds to fill up,” he said.
“I think there’s different products. They have a much larger project in volume and size. Our first floor is only retail, 25,000 square feet. They got a hotel. I think their investment is good for us, and I hope that they’re successful.”
With the mix of retail, office and residential, Stark is hoping to advance a project that creates vibrancy and a 24/7 environment in the heart of the Downtown commercial corridor.
“I think we see more of a live, work, play environment in urban cities and the best way to replicate that is to have that building active 24/7,” Mr. Coven said.
The developer bought the building last year from Oxford Development Co. It originally planned five floors of offices and two floors of retail.
Stark now plans to build the three floors of office space on a speculative basis, but Mr. Coven said it already has had “some interest” from potential tenants.
The apartments will be located on the top floors. As part of the redevelopment, Stark plans to recast the very top floor, which was not part of the original building construction, to better accommodate apartments. The rest of the facade will remain intact.
Stark also is planning underground parking, new sidewalks, and awnings to enliven the space outside of the building. The latter drew praise from planning commission chairwoman Christine Mondor.
“That block needs some life,” she said.
The developer hopes to get started on the project in the 2019 first quarter and have it completed in 20 months.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.