The Federal Aviation Administration has “very significant safety and efficiency concerns” about a proposal to close the longest runway at Pittsburgh International Airport.
In a Nov. 1, 2017, letter, Steven M. Urlass, director of the FAA’s eastern region airports division, stated that a Pittsburgh International master plan recommendation to close runway 10 Right/28 Left made various assumptions that the agency found concerning, specifically related to air traffic management, navigational aids and airport design standards.
The airport is considering the closing at a time when its passenger totals are nowhere near where they were during its years as a hub for the former US Airways — even with the new flights and new airlines that have touched down in Pittsburgh in the past three years.
“During the airport’s initial presentations, all of the involved FAA offices have expressed very significant safety and efficiency concerns with regard to the closing of the primary runway at PIT, including the introduction of unnecessary risks into the operations at the airport,” he wrote.
The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette obtained the letter, written to Allegheny County Airport Authority CEO Christina Cassotis, after filing a Freedom of Information Act request with the FAA.
In an interview, Ms. Cassotis said the “jury is out” on whether runway 10 Right/28 Left ultimately will be closed. She stressed that, like the FAA, the paramount concern of the authority, which operates Pittsburgh International, is safety.
“This is not predetermined. Don’t know which runway would make sense to close and don’t know if it even makes sense. But it would be crazy to not look at it given that we have four runways,” she said.
“So we are exploring it and, of course, the FAA, their first job is to make sure we are running a safe and efficient airfield and that is our first concern. So we would never do anything — ever — that threatens that.”
At 11,500 feet in length, runway 10 Right/28 Left is capable of handling the world’s largest jets. If closed, it would leave the airport with three runways — two for east-west departures and landings and one for northwest-southeast traffic.
In recommending the shut down, the master plan concluded that the runway is in poor condition compared with the other three and would need to undergo reconstruction or major maintenance much sooner than runway 10 Center/28 Center, the other being considered for closing.
The master plan, prepared by Ricondo, an aviation consulting firm, estimated that closing 10 Right/28 Left could save $2 million a year in operation and maintenance costs to the airport and $2.1 million a year in taxiing costs to the airlines.
In its letter, the FAA did not state specifically what safety or efficiency concerns it had or what unnecessary risks could be introduced with the runway’s closing.
But one writer on a website dedicated to local aviation issues suggested that the closing could force planes to twice cross runway 14-32 to take off from runway 10 Center/28 Center, increasing the potential for incursions.
The writer also stated that planes headed back to the terminal after landing on runway 14-32 would use the same taxiway as jets leaving the terminal to take off on runway 10 Center/28 Center.
That would mean that planes may have to wait on one another to pass, potentially negating any fuel savings gained by closing runway 10 Right/28 Left, the farthest from the terminal.
Ms. Cassotis maintained the assertions assume the airport is not planning any other improvements to the airfield to mitigate such concerns in conjunction with the closing.
“I think those concerns are valid and we would be looking at that and that goes to the FAA concerns around safety and efficiency. Again, we don’t know [if the proposal will advance],” she said.
“We would never do anything to compromise safety or efficiency. We won’t. So that assumes that nothing else changes. We have to look at where the concerns are, where the operational and safety concerns are, and if we can’t appropriately mitigate, then we’re not going to do it.”
The master plan stated that the airport uses runway 14-32 only 5 percent of the time, in part for night arrivals as part of a noise abatement program.
In his letter, Mr. Urlass pointed out the potential closing — as well as a $1.1 billion Pittsburgh International modernization plan that involves shutting down the landside building and erecting a new facility for ticketing, security and baggage — would involve a change to the airport layout plan and require a thorough FAA review.
There also would be a need for a safety assessment and environmental clearance.
“Our job is to make sure we maintain the highest possible safety standards. With this in mind, it is crucial that, across all the FAA lines of business, we take a deliberate and collaborative look at any and all consequences associated with your proposed actions,” he stated.
Ms. Cassotis said the entire review could take as much as 18 to 24 months. She expects public meetings over the plan to start this summer.
She has argued that there is no need for four runways at Pittsburgh International given current and projected levels of service. Three would still give Pittsburgh more than London’s Heathrow Airport, which has two, although it is now considering a third.
Runway 10 Right/28 Left opened at Pittsburgh International in 1980 at a time the airport was handling 11.5 million passengers a year. Passenger volume increased dramatically during the region’s years as a hub for the former US Airways, now part of American Airlines. But traffic fell swiftly after the carrier shut down the hub in 2004.
Last year, the airport handled just short of 9 million travelers, its best year since 2007. The master plan projects that the number of passengers using the terminal will increase to 12 million by 2033, or about 500,000 more than in 1980.
Total aircraft operations are expected to climb from 139,300 in 2013 to 166,560 in 2033. That’s still far less than the 336,346 handled in 2004.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.