A Chicago developer’s plan to turn the Strip District’s iconic produce terminal into the “go-to” place in Pittsburgh filled with a food-centric market, restaurants, brew pubs, and outdoor space to sell locally grown produce and other goods edged a step closer to reality Thursday — but not without conditions.

Pittsburgh Urban Redevelopment Authority board members tentatively approved a deal to transfer control of the Strip landmark to McCaffery Interests but not before taking steps to try to protect one of the terminal’s long-term tenants, the Society for Contemporary Craft.

In response to concerns raised at the meeting about the nonprofit’s fate, the board conditioned the transfer on the start of talks with the group on a new lease. It also authorized a 25-day public comment period on the agreement and the plans for the terminal’s revitalization, leaving open the possibility of more changes at its April meeting.

A rendering of the redevelopment plans for the produce terminal in Pittsburgh's Strip District. (McCaffery Interests)

The last-minute conditions mean that McCaffery Interests will have to wait at least another month to complete its four-year quest to gain control of the historic Smallman Street warehouse, now nearly vacant and in poor condition.

Advertise with us

“I’m almost numb to it,” CEO Dan McCaffery said of the latest delay. “What’s 30 days after four years?”

Mr. McCaffery told the board Thursday that he wants to keep the nonprofit in the building at a reduced rent but acknowledged that the group might have to make some concessions as well.

“They’re going to get a very good deal. But I’m also saying there will have to be a level of reasonableness on their side,” he said.

Janet McCall, Society for Contemporary Craft executive director, said Mr. McCaffery on Thursday offered the group the opportunity to stay in the building as a long-term tenant at a rate that gives consideration to its nonprofit status.

She described the offer as a “good place to start negotiations,” adding that the group supports McCaffery’s redevelopment plans and wants to be part of them.

Advertise with us

City Councilwoman Deborah Gross, who represents the Strip, urged the URA, as owner of the building, to extend the group’s lease before transferring control of the terminal to McCaffery.

“Are you going to support commercial gentrification or are you going to protect community spaces, community market space, community nonprofit space?” she asked.

Before the vote, Mr. McCaffery laid out his vision for a massive overhaul of the terminal, one that would include a “food centric” locally owned market at its western end closest to Downtown. The market would feature a chef incubator kitchen, grab-to-go foods, and coffee and cocktail bars. There also would be an adjacent community space that could be used for special events and may include a wine and music lounge.

McCaffery also has agreed to lease at least 40,000 square feet within the complex to local or regional businesses focused on artisan food, crafts, produce, meats and creative arts. There also are plans for restaurants, brew pubs, fitness space, and “urban size” drug and hardware stores to cater to the burgeoning residential population in the Strip.

Outside, an outdoor market and plaza would feature space to sell locally grown fruits and vegetables, harkening back to the terminal’s history as a hub for produce wholesalers, as well as areas for arts and crafts and other activities.

Advertise with us

McCaffery Interests also is proposing three passageways through the1,533-foot building to give visitors access to the Allegheny River from Penn Avenue and Smallman Street

The ideas for the redevelopment are patterned in part after the Ferry Terminal in San Francisco and similar endeavors in Europe as well as local community input. Mr. McCaffery said the goal is to complement the other activity throughout the Strip, including the eclectic mix of markets and stores on Penn Avenue.

The terminal makeover is part of a broader plan that includes the redevelopment of a building across the street at 1600 Smallman that McCaffery has an option to buy and an overhaul of Smallman itself from 16th Street to 21st Street to make it more pedestrian friendly.

In all, Mr. McCaffery said the total cost of the two endeavors and the street improvements would be more that $100 million.

With the tentative approval Thursday, Mr. McCaffery would like to have the terminal overhaul completed by September 2019.

Advertise with us

“We should make it the go-to place in Pittsburgh for any number of things — food, entertainment, the arts,” he said. “I feel pretty good that our gathering place for restaurants, bars, a food-centric market, some small shops and so on, it’s going to be marvelous.”

As part of he tentative deal approved Thursday, McCaffery would pay $2.5 million to lease the building from the URA for 99 years. If McCaffery were to try to transfer the lease, the URA would have the right of first refusal. The language is an attempt to protect the public nature of the property.

After four years after delays and protracted negotiations, one URA board member, Cheryl Hall-Russell, wants nothing more than to move on.

“I’m holding my breath and hoping this works out,” she said.