After more than two years of sparring over the Penn Plaza development in East Liberty, the parties involved have made peace.
The site’s developer, the city of Pittsburgh and neighborhood groups reached a deal Friday that ends all litigation and clears the path for the development to move forward. It also meets the city’s desire to replace lower-income housing lost when the Penn Plaza apartment complex was demolished at the site.
Under a consent order approved in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court on Friday, Pennley Park South, an affiliate of developer LG Realty Advisors, agreed to commit 50 percent of tax abatement funds that it’s entitled to as part of working in a Transit Revitalization Investment District (or TRID) to acquire and develop affordable housing in the area.
In addition, up to $1 million of the funds will be used to rebuild and improve Enright Park, the city park adjacent to the development site.
The total contribution to the housing fund is estimated at around $10 million, ultimately depending on the size of the project.
The plan calls for developing mixed income housing units within a one-mile radius of the development. Among the units, 251 will be affordable and 239 will be market rate, according to the documents.
With the deal in place, Pennley Park will drop its plans for apartments at the site and focus on office and retail uses.
“We are preparing revised plans in accordance with the agreement and will be getting them to the planning commission as soon as possible,” said Jonathan Kamin, attorney for LG Realty Advisors.
Grocery chain Whole Foods Market originally had committed to being the anchor tenant at the site but pulled out because of controversy surrounding the development, which initially was to include 200 apartments along with 12,000-square-feet of offices and some 580 parking spaces in the first phase.
Mr. Kamin on Friday left open the possibility that Whole Foods could re-emerge as part of the project.
“Whole Foods speaks for Whole Foods,” he said. “We would be excited to attract any first quality tenant to such a signature project.”
Whole Foods did not respond to an email Friday seeking comment.
The Penn Plaza project stoked controversy because it displaced residents of the old Penn Plaza apartments, many of whom were elderly and low-income. The development became a flashpoint for broader issues of affordable housing in Pittsburgh.
The city sued Pennley Park, alleging it had engaged in demolition activity — in violation of a 2015 memorandum of understanding — while residents were still living there and failed to provide proper heat for residents who had remained.
Pennley Park filed a counterclaim, charging that it sustained more than $10 million in damages after Whole Foods dropped out amid concerns raised by the city and community.
Friday’s consent agreement was ironed out with the help of attorney William Pietragallo of Pietragallo Gordon Alfano Bosick & Raspanti, who volunteered his time to serve as mediator.
“We are thankful for Bill Pietragallo …and the collaboration of all stakeholders who helped us arrive at this great settlement,” Mr. Kamin said.
He said the hope was to break ground on the development next year and be open for business in late 2019 or early 2020, with the tax abatement-funded housing project being developed simultaneously.
“While I’m happy this settlement was reached, we must remember the many longtime East Liberty residents displaced by this development,” Mayor Bill Peduto said in a statement.
The housing fund created by the agreement should allow many of the roughly 200 displaced residents to ultimately return to affordable apartments in the vicinity, the city said.
Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066. Mark Belko contributed to this story.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.