The developer that had planned to buy the former Mayview State Hospital property has asked South Fayette not to take any further steps to change the zoning of the site, a change that would have been needed for the company to build a residential and commercial development there.
In addition, the developer said, the current owner of the Mayview property may hope eventually to drill on the site.
The developer, Charter Homes & Neighborhoods, based in Lancaster, entered into an agreement in April 2014 with the owner of the Mayview property, Aloe Brothers LLC, to buy four parcels totaling 160 acres for $7.5 million. Charter’s plan calls for creating 620 residences and 100,000 square feet of commercial space in a development that would be called Hastings.
The sales agreement was dependent upon Charter getting the zoning of the property changed from B-1 to a proposed new zone called Neighborhood Design District, and the agreement called for the zoning change to be completed by mid-summer.
In a letter to South Fayette commissioners dated Oct. 19, Anthony Faranda-Diedrich, a vice president with Charter Homes & Neighborhoods, wrote, “Given delays in the zoning amendment process, it is not possible for us to meet deadlines for obtaining zoning and development approvals under our agreement of sale with the owner.”
“Additionally,” Mr. Faranda-Diedrich wrote, “the land owner believes the election results in November may provide an opportunity to overturn the recently passed drilling ordinance, and as a result drill on the site in the future rather then sell the property to us.”
The township’s current oil and gas ordinance restricts drilling to property zoned industrial use only. Mr. Faranda-Diedrich noted that Charter’s acquistion of the property would have precluded drilling on the site.
Aloe Brothers could not be reached for comment.
South Fayette commissioners decided in September to delay a decision on the zoning change after hearing conflicting reports and concerns from the public about whether the proposed development would lead to crowded schools and higher taxes.
The commissioners discussed hiring an independent consultant to review the potential impact of the development but have not done so. The board was expected to vote on the zoning change in November.
The sales agreement, which is a matter of public record, states that Aloe Brothers would keep the oil, gas, and coal subsurface rights. However, under the agreement, Aloe would not interfere with Charter’s use of the property, nor would it use the surface to excise any minerals.
Aloe Brothers bought the property from the state in January 2011. In December 2013, the South Fayette zoning board denied Aloe’s application to mine coal there.
In May 2014, South Fayette filed a declaration to take by eminent domain the surface and subsurface rights to nearly 69 acres of the 160 acres of Mayview property to enlarge Fairview Park to meet residents’ recreational needs. Aloe objected, and the case has ended up in court, with a nonjury trial scheduled for Feb. 18, 2016.
Amy Philips-Haller, freelance writer; suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.