Apartments, collaborative office space or a possible ice hockey rink are the options under consideration for the reuse of the Hunt Armory in Shadyside.
Plans for the redevelopment of the century-old landmark will be presented at a public meeting to be held Monday from 6 to 7:30 p.m. at Calvary Episcopal Church at 315 Shady Ave.
The city’s Urban Redevelopment Authority has narrowed the search for a redeveloper to three finalists — Shadyside-based Walnut Capital; a partnership between McKnight Realty Partners and the Mosites Co., both based Downtown; and Kratsa Properties in Harmar.
Walnut is proposing to convert the former military training center and storage space for weapons and ammunition into a residential complex with 106 apartments, about 80 percent of which would be one bedroom.
In addition to the apartments, Walnut is proposing a landscaped courtyard that will be accessible to the public, and Sacred Heart Elementary School across the street can use it for recess.
Walnut, which is teaming with Massaro Properties on the project, is best known for its Bakery Square and Bakery Square 2.0 developments in the East End featuring office, retail, hotel and residential space.
Read More
McKnight and Mosites are pitching plans for a business incubator at the Armory built around 120,000 to 140,000 square feet of collaborative office space. There also are plans for a climbing wall (why not with an 85-foot-high roof), recreational and community programmed arts-related space, and about 80 indoor parking spaces.
The concept is patterned after Brooklyn Boulders, a company that combines collaborative workspace with recreational amenities like climbing walls with locations in New York, Chicago and Boston.
McKnight owns several office buildings Downtown, including the Heinz 57 Center and the Grant Building, while Mosites is best known for its Eastside developments in East Liberty that include Whole Foods Market, Target, and a new transit center.
The third proposal, by Kratsa, involves a possible ice rink. Few other details were available Monday. Kratsa officials couldn’t be reached for comment.
URA officials declined to discuss the proposals in advance of Monday’s meeting, which they and city Councilman Dan Gilman, who represents Shadyside, are sponsoring.
Mr. Gilman said he has no preference among the finalists at this point but stressed that he wants to see a development that has a positive impact on the community, mitigates negative impacts like parking, and honors the history of the site.
The meeting will be the first at which the finalists’ proposals will be discussed.
“It’s a complicated redevelopment that has a lot of impact on the community. When government is going to be involved in that kind of project, it is important for the community to be heard,” Mr. Gilman said.
Former state Sen. Jim Ferlo, a URA board member, said he favors the “highest and best use” for the property, a development that maximizes the historic character of the building, will generate the most money for the structure and requires no public subsidies. He believes the “most responsible activity” would be high quality residential because of the tax revenue it would generate.
Built in 1916, the armory featuring 90,904 square feet of interior space at one time was the city’s largest auditorium, hosting the likes of evangelist the Rev. Billy Graham and hard rockers Led Zeppelin.
Owned by the state, which has been selling its National Guard armories, the building was acquired for $1 by the URA in January with an eye toward redevelopment. Eighty percent of what the URA gets in any resale to a developer would be returned to the state.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.