Uncertainty seems to have settled over Shady Hill Center in Shadyside.
Some merchants have been told their store leases will not be renewed, fueling rumors about the shopping center’s future.
One day the rumor is that the plaza’s Giant Eagle grocery store will expand, become a Market District and push out other merchants. The next, it’s that developer Walnut Capital has bought a large chunk of the parking lot with redevelopment in mind.
Neither rumor is true.
Whatever happens to Giant Eagle, it will not become a Market District, a company spokesman said. And Walnut Capital has not bought any part of the parking lot, said Gregg Perelman, Walnut Capital CEO and founder.
Beyond that, nobody is saying a whole lot.
Read More
Giant Eagle is “evaluating the use of the store property,” which sits near the East Liberty border, spokesman Dick Roberts said recently.
As for what purpose, “That’s the $64,000 question,” Mr. Roberts said, adding that it’s “probably too premature to talk about it.”
“It’s definitely not going to be a Market District,” he stressed, noting that Giant Eagle already has such a store about a half-dozen or so blocks away on Centre Avenue near Whole Foods Market.
Thomas Karet, CEO of Echo Realty, which owns the plaza and is landlord to Giant Eagle and the other tenants, said he’s not sure what the future holds. He’s waiting for Giant Eagle to decide what it wants to do.
“The short answer is that we don’t know what we are going to do yet,” he said.
However, Echo officials are “keeping our options open” by not renewing the leases of “a bunch of tenants,” he said. The current merchants in the plaza are a state liquor store, Family Dollar, Modern Hair Beauty Supply, Rent-A-Center and Dollar Bank.
All of the leases expire next year, Mr. Karet said. That does not necessarily mean that the stores will be leaving.
“We’ve extended leases in the past on a year-to-year basis. We could do that. There’s obviously a lot of redevelopment in that neck of the woods. It would be great for us to improve the plaza, but it really depends on what Giant Eagle wants to do,” he said.
No doubt, the center — sometimes referred to as the Shakespeare Street plaza — is ripe for redevelopment.
Not only does it have a dated 1960s look, it’s across the street from the new Mosites Co.’s Eastside III development, which will feature 360 apartments, 40,000 square feet of retail and a 524-space parking garage, all built around a $52 million transit center.
A bridge will connect the Shady Avenue area around the plaza to Eastside III. Furthermore, the East Liberty Target is less than two blocks away, and the Bakery Square and Bakery Square 2.0 office and apartment developments are just down the road.
Asked what he wanted Giant Eagle to do, Mr. Karet said, “I would like to see them make some sort of significant investment in a new facility. That would be my preference. But, of course, they don’t always do what I want them to do.”
Echo is the grocery’s development arm and largest landlord, though it is an independent company.
The supermarket chain told Mr. Karet it is doing research and did not have the results yet. He is hoping for a decision within six months.
Giant Eagle and Echo had considered renovating the supermarket and adding a GetGo and a coffee shop or drive-through bank to the plaza 10 years ago, but the plans ended up being dropped.
City Councilman Dan Gilman, who represents Shadyside, stressed that it’s “critical” that the Giant Eagle remain, noting the store is heavily used by East End residents. Beyond that, a “denser development, more urban in design, would be a benefit to the neighborhood,” he said.
“I think it’s one of the most valuable parcels in the city of Pittsburgh and it’s being heavily underutilized,” he said.
Maelene Myers, executive director of East Liberty Development Inc., would like to see the Giant Eagle reconfigured, with amenities like dry cleaning added. She also would like to see the loading dock on the Penn Avenue side of the plaza repositioned to create a more inviting environment.
Inja Kim, owner of Modern Hair Beauty Supply in the plaza, has heard all the rumors. She’s sure of only one thing: Her lease expires at the end of 2016 and apparently won’t be renewed. It could spell the end for a store that has been in the plaza 23 years.
“They gave to us the notice. We don’t have any choice,” she said.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.