For fans awaiting the opening of Toby Keith’s I Love This Bar and Grill on the North Shore, it looks like hope is on the rocks, to paraphrase one of country singer’s songs.

After a long courtship, the restaurant won’t be anchoring the North Shore Place I and II retail and office complex developed by Continental Real Estate Cos. next to Stage AE.

“We are looking for a replacement for Toby Keith,” said Barry Ford, Continental’s president of development in Pittsburgh.

The Columbus-based developer has a “couple of good options on the table” for taking the space, Mr. Ford said, noting that he was “very optimistic” about the prospects of finding a replacement.

Advertise with us

“We need someone who wants to combine music and food, and we’ll do that,” added Frank Kass, Continental’s chairman.

Continental was counting on the restaurant to anchor the complex’s high-profile, 16,000-square-foot corner spot on North Shore Drive, creating a synergy with Stage AE, Jerome Bettis Grille 36 and nearby Heinz Field. The North Shore seemed like a perfect spot for Mr. Keith, a big Steelers fan.

Much of the space for the restaurant — including its trademark guitar-shaped bar — already had been built out.

“It was almost done,” Mr. Kass said.

Asked how much the developer had spent finishing the space, he replied, “A lot.”

Advertise with us

Continental isn’t the only developer in Pittsburgh to pursue the chain only to come up empty.

The Soffer Organization announced in 2009 that Toby Keith’s I Love This Bar and Grill would be opening at SouthSide Works on the Monongahela riverfront in late 2010.

That never happened, and Soffer ended up suing the chain in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court, claiming that it did not live up to its lease obligations.

The lawsuit sought a judgment of $460,005 against CRGE Pittsburgh LLC, an arm of Toby Keith’s I Love This Bar and Grill.

It claimed that CRGE defaulted on the lease agreement by failing to provide financial statements and evidence of equity financing. CRGE lawyers contested the allegations.

Advertise with us

The last record in the case in 2013 indicates that the judgment had been satisfied.

Meanwhile, Pittsburgh isn’t the only city experiencing problems with the restaurant chain.

Toby Keith’s I Love This Bar and Grill locations have closed in San Bernardino, Calif.; Cincinnati; Denver; Orlando; Phoenix; Syracuse; Houston; Tucson; and Newport News.

Workers at the Cincinnati location filed a class-action lawsuit in August, claiming they weren’t paid after the restaurant abruptly closed two days after the Major League All-Star Game in July.

An investigation by the Arizona Republic newspaper published last month reported that Boomtown Entertainment LLC, which operates Toby Keith restaurants, had closed 17 of its 20 venues and that it, affiliates and executives were facing at least $28 million in lawsuits, judgments and liens.

Advertise with us

The newspaper also reported that, since 2012, Boomtown had announced plans to build 19 Toby Keith restaurants that ended up being left unfinished or never started.

Gregory McClure, Boomtown’s executive vice president and general counsel, said in a 2012 interview that CRGE Pittsburgh was separate from Boomtown. Mr. McClure is listed as the agent on the incorporation papers for CRGE North Shore. He could not be reached for comment Monday.

Boomtown officials have attributed the shutdowns nationwide to an aggressive new business plan. Jess Lorona, Boomtown’s outside counsel, told the Arizona Republic that restaurants were closed or not opened based on finances. Some, he said, didn’t make money and had to be shut down.

On the North Shore, Continental, which was hired by the Steelers and the Pirates to develop land between Heinz Field and PNC Park, recently opened a Burgatory at North Shore Place I and II.

Bar Louie also has plans to open a 6,524-square-foot restaurant in the complex. A North Park Lounge also is planned for the three-story complex, where the Post-Gazette is one of the tenants.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.