Pittsburgh’s Zoning Board of Adjustment heard a proposal Thursday for an eight-story, 72-unit apartment building behind a row of historic facades on North Avenue at Federal Street.
It would be TREK Development Group’s first phase in bringing life back to the Garden Theater block, which has been languishing for years.
The project would need a variance to build higher than the current maximum height of 45 feet, which is roughly three stories, to make the investment viable, said Bill Gatti, founder and president of TREK Development. TREK has the Garden Theater under contract and is scheduled to close later this month. The previous developer of the theater, Zukin Development, is bowing out of the process.
Mr. Gatti said his group went into the process intending to preserve what was possible. The first option — to restore the buildings and bring them up to code — would result in 15 units pricing out at $381,547 per unit.
The second option was to restore the buildings and build additions behind them at the same height. This would have provided 24 units at $359,000 per unit, he said.
With 68-72 units, the price per unit comes to $258,000 and allows for some rents to be in the $800 and $900 range. The higher-end apartments would cost $2,640, “which is marginally acceptable in the North Side market,” he said.
“There is no chance the [current] buildings would be economically viable” under the first two options, he said.
With the third option in play, the facades at 4, 6 and 8 W. North Ave. and 30 feet of their depth would be incorporated into the new construction.
The project needs three special exceptions for parking. The plan calls for the use of off-site parking nearby, with a reduction in the number of spaces required.
City Councilwoman Darlene Harris said she was concerned that the plan didn’t take into account the current heavy use of the parking garage behind the site, which the Urban Redevelopment Authority built with the condition that 150 of its 500 spaces be set aside for the public benefit and redevelopment of the immediate area.
Mr. Gatti said he is in negotiation with the garage owner to procure the needed parking spaces.
The zoning board is expected to rule on the matter in about 60 days.
Representatives of the Allegheny City Central Association, the Mexican War Streets — a preservation group — and the Pittsburgh History & Landmarks Foundation spoke in support of TREK’s plan. The project is located in the neighborhood represented by ACCA.
Although the standing-room-only hearing room was dominated by project supporters, the zoning board asked them not to take the time to testify if their points had already been stated by the neighborhood groups and the developer. It did allow five people to speak against the plan, which they said is out of balance with the rest of the neighborhood and would set a precedent for tall development in Allegheny West.
Two argued that they would lose views from their homes.
Cathy Serventi, president of the Allegheny West Civic Council, spoke on behalf of its board, which voted against the project by supporting current zoning restrictions.
“We have properties bordering the park [Allegheny Commons] that, if this is approved, will have similar types of requests,” she said.
Alice Mitinger, chair of the zoning board, said the board does not consider other projects or precedents when making its decisions.
Correction (posted Aug. 7): This article has been updated to give the correct capacity of the parking garage behind the site. Also, the passage about testimony from individuals who support the project has been expanded, along with a passage about the neighborhood location of the project.
Diana Nelson Jones: djones@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1626.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.