Andrew Sassaman, branch manager for Robert Half Management Resources, Downtown, noticed the shift shortly after Thanksgiving: The competition for top job candidates is tightening.

After four years of having their pick for professional position applicants willing to make a lateral move, or even take a pay cut, hiring managers now need to adjust their thinking and their techniques or risk losing their first choice, says Mr. Sassaman.

While overall unemployment figures for Pittsburgh have dipped below 7 percent, the figure is below 4 percent locally in areas such as accounting and information technology, he said.

"You want to make sure you get your top choice, and that may mean offering a better compensation package and selling them on why they want to be part of your company."

Advertise with us

Conversely, he added, one of the biggest mistakes employers may make is low-balling a good candidate to save a few thousand dollars in annual salary. That strategy that may have worked a year ago, but now it may only breed resentment in the new hire -- who may then continue the job search while on your payroll.

"That's not a great impression to make on somebody who wants to be part of your team," Mr. Sassaman said.

Matthew Proman, founder of the New York-based National Association of Professional Women, said top candidates are always hard to attract. "The market is soft in certain areas, but in others, good talent is hard to find."

Because current employers want to keep top talent, he said, luring them away means paying attention to details such as writing job descriptions that will catch their eye, and going beyond the traditional resume-review-and-interview approach. He also recommends using recruiting specialists for those key positions.

"The best people are not posting through the normal means."

Advertise with us

Mr. Sassaman has some key recommendations for attracting, then keeping, the best man or woman for the job.

It starts with a detailed job description, rather than some vaguely worded offer that will results in dozens of unqualified applications filling your inbox. In a Robert Half survey of chief financial officers last fall, the single biggest reason for a "failed hire" cited after poor performance was new hires whose skill set did not match up with the job requirements.

"Take the time to figure out what skills you need," Mr. Sassaman said.

Then there are the intangibles -- does the job call for a team player, someone who works well on his own or a combination of both?

Making that determination requires making a personal connection with the applicant, meaning more than one interview and meeting that individual in a more casual setting for coffee or lunch. While he doesn't recommend running an applicant through a gauntlet of seven interviews with seven different managers -- "You're not going to see them in their best light" -- Mr. Sassaman said it is important to get more than one opinion on the applicant's suitability.

Advertise with us

Most of all, he emphasized, be aware that the hiring landscape is changing.

"We now have candidates who are getting multiple offers or counteroffers and temporary hires who are being offered full-time positions."