Salad bars represent all that's good and bad in the world. They offer us the ability to eat food that's good for us -- from spinach (good for the body) to olives (good for the soul) to dressings (good for the taste buds). But they also can be riddled with germs -- remember that kid who sneezed and then poked his finger in the dressing to have a taste before applying it to his salad? Sneeze shields have been standard equipment for years on salad bars, yet, even if you're not a germaphobe, you can't help but be wary of the food that's sitting there.

Enter the Robotic Salad Bar -- I kid you not -- one of the creative ideas I recently saw at Enterprise Forum Pittsburgh's elevator pitch session. If you're not familiar with the world of elevator pitches, I'll attempt to enlighten you in 60 seconds or less -- because that's how long Uday Roy had to present his entire salad bar concept to a panel of four and 100 additional people filling the room to hear business ideas from Mr. Roy, of Deming Systems, and a dozen other entrepreneurial hopefuls.

These entrepreneurs were hoping to use their minute in the spotlight to persuade potential investors in the crowd to consider pushing money in their direction. The concept is meant to parallel the situation in which an entrepreneur is lucky enough to be alone in an elevator of a tall building with a potential funder. By the time the funder gets off on his floor, he must be persuaded to meet with the entrepreneur to learn more and talk about an investment.

While Mr. Roy was on the virtual elevator, he painted a vivid picture of a product that removes the dangers of a standard salad bar. In his robotic version, the entire salad bar is enclosed by a glass shield. A robotic arm picks up your dish and by pushing buttons you can go down the line and get exactly the salad that you want as the robotic arms fill your dish with whatever you select.

Advertise with us

As you might expect, the idea produced tongue-in-cheek responses from the panels made up of local executives who have been involved in startups and funding who were there to offer comments and advice to the presenters. Gary Gardiner from Idea Foundry asked if it could do ice cream. Craig Gomulka of Innovation Works recast it as "a salad bar for hypochondriacs," which prompted the evening's moderator, David Gurwin of Buchanan Ingersoll & Rooney to quip, "but somebody has to touch the button."

That touch of humor was evident throughout the evening, even as the panelists gave sound advice to entrepreneurs, some of whom had probably never presented their ideas before.

Some of the ideas were completely new; but most were spins on ideas that have already reached the market.

Rob Myer, founder of NoWait, proposed a Web service that helps you minimize the annoyances related to getting a seat in a casual dining restaurant. Jason Wilburn of software development company, BlenderHouse, offered to use predictive technology to solve a $20 billion problem of the health-care industry -- waste from health-care documentation.

The big winner of the evening, by consensus of the panel, was ChroKnow's Sam Rothstein, who used the concept of a shot for HIV lasting an entire year to present a way he can help make drug development 100 times faster. It was a compelling idea, presented in a compelling way -- and got a vote from all four panelists for top elevator pitch.

Now, all these folks need is some money.