On May 25, Facebook founder and CEO Mark Zuckerberg announced that the company would be simplifying its privacy settings. As the media were quick to point out, his announcement was a reaction to the furor caused by Facebook users and observers after Facebook rolled out significant changes to what it does with your private information and third parties. The media also pointed out that Mr. Zuckerberg did not apologize for the decisions that created the uproar.

Should Mr. Zuckerberg apologize?

During the past several years, his company has faced a number of situations in which it was roasted by the press and its own users for decisions that were not privacy sensitive. But it's the users who are deciding to continue with Facebook.

Of course Mr. Zuckerberg should have apologized. He put private information in harm's way for hundreds of millions of people. But I would not have expected him to be at all apologetic because Facebook is not built for privacy. It's built for sharing intimate details. Without that happening, the company's business model would break down. It thrives by putting users' private information at risk.

Advertise with us

I'm not suggesting that the company should continue to put information at risk -- quite the opposite. It still can be a huge, profitable company without doing so. But they'd have to change the way they do business, and I suspect that it would be difficult to change so drastically in the face of such success.

Despite being opposed to Facebook's privacy attitude, I must also state that the media in one way have treated the company unfairly -- by complaining about the complexity of Facebook's privacy settings. I have been involved in creating privacy settings for Internet services -- and it's not easy. In order to give people choices, it is likely to be complicated. The complexity shouldn't be at issue. The methodology should.

The recent changes at Facebook that increased the privacy risk for users were done without giving the users the ability to protect their information in advance. The default settings were made to share, not protect the information. The changes were apparent only if you read about them in other sources. And the access to the settings was not as easy as it should have been. These are all significant issues, causing many users to shut down their Facebook accounts altogether.

Mr. Zuckerberg and his company didn't feel the need to apologize. And he didn't. He merely announced that it would simplify the task of overriding Facebook's default settings. In essence, he was saying that he is completely insensitive to the privacy needs of his users.

The company already had made the changes that put the information at risk -- such as automatically sharing with third parties information about a Facebook user who had not explicitly logged out of his Facebook account before moving on to the next page in his browser -- and he made no announcement about changing it back. He got what he wanted. Now all he has to do is keep users from defecting, and he'll have accomplished his goal. Most of them won't even bother changing their privacy settings -- even after Facebook makes them simpler.

Advertise with us

I use Facebook infrequently and only when needed; then I log out every time I leave a Facebook page. I changed my privacy settings, and constantly monitor to see if anybody I know has put up too much information on his Facebook page about my family -- and ask him or her to remove it. I harp on my teenagers about the amount of information they share -- sometimes effectively and sometimes in vain.

And I keep my fingers crossed.