Like most new graduates, when Riley Crow wrapped up his degree in film at the University of Pittsburgh last August, he began to job hunt — with one criterion in mind: an in-person position.
“I wanted to go into an office,” said Mr. Crow, zooming from his desk at the Jewish Community Center of Greater Pittsburgh, where he handles marketing. “I wanted the whole adult life experience.”
Mr. Crow, 24, wanted to make friends at his new job, to network face to face, to “you know — schmooze,” he said. “Remote work felt like the work of the future for about a year. But I think it got old.”
Bad news for workers like Mr. Crow: The data is clear — remote work isn’t going anywhere anytime soon.
A 2024 Gallup report found that more U.S. adults worked fully remote than fully in-office — 29% compared to 20%. The remaining half worked hybrid, and 9 in 10 were content with this new norm, preferring some degree of remote flexibility.
And if Downtown Pittsburgh is any indication, the bustling cubicles of prepandemic days are not filling back up.
‘They want to be mentored’
Enter Gen Z — the generation that attended Zoom Bat Mitzvahs and virtual college orientation — and the story gets more complicated.
Gallup released a new poll in late July: Gen Z workers in the U.S. are the least likely generation to prefer exclusively remote work. They lag behind Millennials and even Boomers in their likelihood to apply for remote positions on LinkedIn, according to the platform’s 2023 State of the Labor Market report.
With these folks — now aged 13 to 28 — set to make up just under a third of the total workforce by 2030, according to a McKinsey report, experts say Gen Z’s hesitancy to log back onto Zoom full time reveals drawbacks of remote work that impact everyone.
Pittsburgh Gen Zs cite concerns over stymied early career development and social isolation.
Yet, some are perfectly happy to build their adult lives around remote work.
Tim Currie, author of “SwiftTrust: Mastering Relationships in the Remote Work Revolution,” has spent decades building tech consulting firms and studying what makes organizations work.
“There’s a couple of factors that come into play that make more of an impact on Gen Z,” Mr. Currie said. “One is that they’re at the early stages of their career. They want to be mentored. They want to build strong interpersonal relationships. They want to identify and feel like they’re part of something.”
When a workplace moves online, co-worker relationships collapse to include only direct chains of command, Mr. Curries said. They also become more task-based, transactional.
In short, early career employees learn from and connect with fewer people.
“While anyone from any demographic might feel that loss, it’s really important when you’re young,” Mr. Currie said.
‘Coming into work is a huge pleasure’
Mr. Crow, who graduated from Pitt in 2023, identified another difference between older and younger employees: priorities.
Most older adults are focused on completing tasks and taking care of homes, families, or relationships, he said, while Gen Z workers are still focused on developing as individuals.
“You can develop professionally from home. I don’t think you can develop as a human being,” he said.
Remote life also was “old” to him by the time he entered the workforce. His entire sophomore year of college was done exclusively over Zoom, “with a muted mic and turned-off camera,” he said.
During that period, he became anxious and antisocial. In-person work seemed like a natural antidote to the “brain mush” much of Gen Z developed during the pandemic, he said.
Although he would have taken any job that came his way after graduating, he feels lucky to work in person.
“Coming into work is a huge pleasure,” Mr. Crow said. “But I think for older people, remote work is newer to them, and it allows them to take care of their priorities that I’m too young to have right now.
“There’s nothing for me to do in my apartment by myself, where I live alone.”
‘That life is not real’
For Mr. Crow and his friends who have started hybrid jobs, remote days feel more like time off.
“I don’t want to work tomorrow, becomes I’m going to work from home,” he said.
Trent Seitz, a second-year international business student at Washington & Jefferson College, agreed, saying his desire for an in-person office job is less socially driven and more practical. Remote work would impact his productivity.
“I really like being surrounded by like-minded people that all have one goal,” Mr. Seitz said.
He remembers ninth grade on Zoom, when his productivity suffered. He was still completing tasks, but his focus was split between personal and school-related work.
Among his fellow business majors, “the consensus is a lot of people like remote work” he said. “But too much of it can really hurt.
“Your productivity for your primary job is increased when you’re in the office, but personally, it can feel like you’re more productive at home because you’re getting multiple things done.”
When Mr. Seitz graduates in 2027, he said he “definitely” wants to work in-person in an office.
Max Rosen started working for AdSkate, a Pittsburgh-based AI advertising startup, in person after he graduated from Boston University in 2024. Three weeks ago, he moved to New York, and now works remotely.
“Being in person, I think, was a huge accelerator for me,” he said. “Fully remote work is tough for a lot of young people. This is the time where you’re building a life, and that life is not real if you’re not going out and having interactions.”
But, so far, remote work has been great for Mr. Rosen’s music, which he writes and records in addition to his tech work, he said.
Such flexibility, he said, is nice.
‘A very shallow kind of coping mechanism’
Polina Neft doesn’t have that flexibility — and sometimes she wishes she did.
Managing Serenity Wig Salon in Squirrel Hill is a strictly hands-on job.
Ms. Neft graduated from Pitt in 2022 after studying economics — mostly over Zoom.
“It was a very unpopular opinion, but I loved doing school from home,” she said. “I would schedule school around my life, and not my life around school.”
She said she misses that freedom, but added that she loves her job and values her clients — which is why she is happy to forgo working from home.
Still, she also misses the freedom and flexibility of remote work.
“I love my alone time. I like that to be something that I can control, when I get to be around people,” Ms. Neft said.
Mr. Currie, the author, documented this phenomenon in his book — where employees see their personal lives as entirely disconnected from workplaces.
The term “swift trust” originated in the early 2000s, when tech companies began organizing global teams, Mr. Currie said. These teams worked together for a number of months, but the trust they developed was transactional.
“What I found in my research is that what we would normally consider swift trust was being applied almost indefinitely and permanently in remote settings,” Mr. Currie said. “People would say, ‘my employer trusts me to do the task I’m assigned, and I trust them to pay me.’ But it’s a very shallow kind of coping mechanism for organizational trust that would normally develop in a traditional environment.”
Trust happens when we reveal ourselves over time, Mr. Currie said.
And right now, Mr. Currie said, “There is not yet a good way to do that in a 100% remote workplace.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.