The Securities and Exchange Commission will soon consider a rule change that advocates say will goose investments in small businesses.

The Small Business Capital Formation Advisory Committee on Monday recommended lifting the $124,000 limit on crowdfunded investment requests to $350,000 before tripping an SEC mandate for independently certified financial reports from the borrower. The requirement can add thousands in fees, cutting into the monies raised.

The goal is to ease the capital costs for fledgling businesses that use online crowdfunding platforms to raise money. No date has been set for the full SEC review of the recommendation.

“We don’t want to eliminate the requirement, but rather eliminate the requirement where it’s onerous,” committee chair Erica Duignan said at the hearing.

Advertise with us

Committee member Aren Sharifi voted against the move, saying, “I just don’t have the data to say whether $350,000 makes sense. I’m not sure I agree with it.”

Entrepreneurs often turn to family and friends for money in the early going of building a business. After that, Small Business Administration-based bank loans have historically been the next stop, and in more recent years, investment crowdfunding through an SEC-approved online portal has offered competitive interest rates for borrowing.

But here’s the rub: For loans exceeding $124,000, the SEC requires financials prepared by an independent third party. That can add between $5,000 to $10,000 to the cost of the capital for the borrower, said George Cook, co-founder and CEO of East Liberty-based Honeycomb Credit, an online business crowdfunding platform.

He thinks the higher limit will spur more investment in small businesses.

“Access to capital by traditional providers is essentially gone,” said Mr. Cook, who is also a member of the SEC committee. “The better capitalized the business, the better the outcome.”

Advertise with us

Borrowers already provide Honeycomb with Internal Revenue Service tax filings, he said, which are used to vet the loan.

For the year ending Sept. 30, 2023, the Pittsburgh office of the Small Business Administration had approved loans totaling $201 million through its flagship 7a program, according to Kelly Hunt, district director, up 12% from $179.4 million in 2019.

Borrowers typically pay the prime interest rate plus three points in interest for the loans, which range up to $5 million.

That means SBA borrowers in Western Pennsylvania could expect to pay a current interest rate of about 11.5%. Local lending institutions make the loans, with the SBA’s backing.

“Without us coming in with the guarantee on the money, many of these banks won’t make the loan,” Ms. Hunt said.

Advertise with us

Square Cafe owner Sherree Goldstein has turned to Honeycomb Credit three times for three business loans since 2020, including a recent $124,000 crowdfunded investment loan to upgrade kitchen equipment and buy new restaurant furniture. Her interest rates ranged between 6.5% and 10%.

“We had a great experience,” she said.

Honeycomb charges borrowers a flat online posting fee of $450, which includes filming a video introducing the business and the purpose of the loan, then a 6% to 8% fee on the borrowed amount — but only if the business meets its fundraising goal. Otherwise, investments are returned to investors who share in making the loan.

Through Honeycomb, Ms. Goldstein raised $250,000 in just 47 days to move her store to East Liberty from Regent Square in 2020. Two years earlier, she raised $35,000 in just 36 hours to open a specialty grocery in Regent Square.

Had the SEC’s $124,000 limit been lifted in her latest fundraising round last year, she said she would certainly have drawn a bigger loan to upgrade electric service to her building. Additional capacity is needed to switch her stoves to energy efficient electricity from natural gas.

Advertise with us

“We’re maxed out on electricity,” she said. “We’ve been working with Duquesne Light on a new transformer for the building, which is from the 1880s.”

Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com