In February, the unemployment rate for the Pittsburgh metropolitan area fell to 3.2%, the lowest local unemployment rate since 1970.

The area’s labor market has made a remarkable recovery since the pandemic when the unemployment rate peaked at almost 17% in April 2020. The local unemployment rate has been below the national rate for the last seven months, the first time that has happened in almost a decade.

But while the historically low Pittsburgh unemployment rate does reflect a huge improvement in the area’s job market from the pandemic, it is not entirely good news. The decades-low unemployment rate is also indicative of a more worrisome long-term trend — the area’s contracting labor force.

Let’s start by defining the unemployment rate.

Advertise with us

The national unemployment rate is calculated using a monthly survey of U.S. households. The Bureau of Labor Statistics asks whether those 16 or older in the household are either employed or unemployed.

To be employed one must be working at a paid job, be self-employed, be temporarily absent from work, or be working for at least 15 hours unpaid in a business owned by a family member. To be unemployed one must be available for work and have made an active effort over the previous four weeks to look for a job. That is, people who don’t have a paid job because they’re raising a child or retired aren’t counted as unemployed; neither is someone who isn’t working but also isn’t actively looking for a job.

The labor force is the sum of those who are either employed or unemployed, basically those who are either working or are actively looking for work. And the unemployment rate is the number of people who are unemployed divided by the number of people in the labor force.

While the national rate is calculated from this survey of households, the BLS estimates unemployment rates for smaller areas (states and counties) using the national data and then data on local labor market conditions, such as surveys of employers and unemployment insurance data.

The local unemployment rate is estimated using the data from the seven counties that make up the Pittsburgh metropolitan area: Allegheny, Armstrong, Beaver, Butler, Fayette, Washington and Westmoreland.

Advertise with us

So in February there were an estimated 1.185 million people in the Pittsburgh-area labor force, either working or looking for work; 1.145 million of them were employed; 38,000 were unemployed; and the unemployment rate was 3.2%.

While the national unemployment rate goes back to 1948, the Bureau of Labor Statistics data for the Pittsburgh metro area only goes back to 1990. But regional economist Chris Briem from the University of Pittsburgh has a historical time series using data provided by the state going back to 1970.

While there are slight methodological differences across the long-run history, Briem’s data put the current Pittsburgh labor market in historical context. And by that measure the current unemployment rate of 3.2% is extremely low. The last time the local unemployment rate was that low was the beginning of 1970, when steel production, still the lynchpin of the local economy and the U.S. was at the tail end of what was, at that time, the longest expansion in the nation’s history.

But there’s a concern hidden in the current very low local unemployment rate.

One reason that the unemployment rate is so low is because the Pittsburgh-area labor force is contracting: there are fewer people working and looking for work. Right before the pandemic there were about 1.22 million people in the local labor force; as of February that number is 1.18 million, or a contraction of about 40,000. The number of jobs in the local economy is actually down by about 2% from before the pandemic; the unemployment rate has fallen because the number of willing and able local workers is down by about 3%.

Advertise with us

While the pandemic exacerbated the area’s labor force issues, this has been a long-standing problem.

Thus the historically low Pittsburgh unemployment rate reflects, in large part, the area’s weak demographics. Every year more people move out of Pittsburgh than move in; the area lags the rest of the U.S. in attracting immigrants from abroad; and an older population means that retirements are a drag on the labor force.

While the low local unemployment rate does mean strong wage growth as businesses raise pay to recruit workers, a contracting labor force will be a significant drag on long-run job growth in the Pittsburgh area as firms look elsewhere for employees.

— Gus Faucher is senior vice president and chief economist of The PNC Financial Services Group. He shares his insights on the regional economy each month.