It was a normal Thursday at Brunton Dairy farm. Ed Brunton was milking the cows with his nephew. His brother Herb was loading the truck.

And then it was anything but normal — Herb looked towards the milking barn, saw smoke coming from a window, grabbed a fire extinguisher and ran towards the plume. Then he noticed more smoke billowing out of the eaves. Then he watched the ceiling catch fire.

“That’s when we called the fire department,” Herb Brunton said. “Me and my nephew Jim got the trucks out of the dock and then everyone went in to get the cows out.”

The flames — at Brunton Dairy, a seventh-generation dairy farm in Independence Township in Beaver County — quickly engulfed the barn and the building next to it.

Advertise with us

“In a half hour, there was nothing left,” Ed Brunton said.

The Oct. 26 fire tore through the milking barn and bottling plant and completely halted the farm's operations. But even more startling than the flames’ destruction, the Bruntons said, are the ongoing efforts of surrounding communities to uplift and support the farm.

“It started with the trailers,” Ed Brunton said. “I was getting cows out and there were already people here. They were coming in across the top of that hill and down that dirt road. The top of the hill was just lined with lights.”

The Oct. 26 fire tore through the milking barn and bottling plant and completely halted the farm's operations. But even more startling than the flames’ destruction, the Bruntons said, are the ongoing efforts of surrounding communities to uplift and support the farm. (Brunton Dairy)

‘All of these people want to help’

Neighbors came with trailers to haul the 84 surviving dairy cows to other local farms — including Craig Family Farm and Linden Creek Dairy — even as firefighters fought the flames.

“The support was immediate,” Herb Brunton said.

Advertise with us

“Overwhelming,” Ed Brunton said. “It all means a lot.”

And it was just the beginning.

The following weekend, the Brunton’s kept the dairy store open to sell the remainder of their stock. Neighbors, friends and customers came by to check in on the Bruntons. Then Alanna Oros, Jerry Brunton’s sister-in-law, and Shawna Vinisky, a Brunton family friend, created a GoFundMe to support recovery efforts. It’s raised over $170,000.

“It's a very small, tight-knit community,” Ms. Oros said. “Everyone knows everyone and everyone's here to help. We kind of went back and forth about whether we should start a GoFundMe. And then finally, at 10 at night we hurried up, and got it together. We published it and by the next morning, we were at $5,000.”

Ms. Oros is not surprised with the community’s support, she said.

Advertise with us

“They're such a good family and they will do anything to help anyone,” she said. “And they're known all over. They have their milk as far as Butler to Canonsburg. When it happened, I was just sitting at home crying and my niece was at the farm. She ran into the burning barn to get her cows out. She's only 12 years old. It's just heartwarming that all of these people want to help.”

Flames quickly engulfed the barn and the building next to it – “in a half hour there was nothing left,” Ed Brunton said. The Brunton Dairy Fire in Beaver County on October 26, 2023. (Gavin Thunberg)

‘One step at a time’

Brunton products are sold throughout Allegheny, Beaver and Butler counties at more than 35 retailers, from small business to sprawling Giant Eagle stores. They have 800 private customers and sell milk at the farm to visitors.

Operations will not be resuming anytime soon, Ed and Herb Brunton said. They need time to rebuild and recover.

But the family hopes to reopen sometime next year.

“We’ve been hounded by phone calls to find out when we're going to be back up and running,” Ed Brunton said. “It's one step at a time. We’ve got to start with building and then find all the right equipment. We’re too little to use equipment for big dairies, but we’re too big to use equipment from the little dairies so we’re sort of stuck in the middle. And the equipment isn’t always easy to find. So right now we’re just cleaning things up.

Advertise with us

“There’s 1,000 decisions to be made and not a whole lot of information.”

It would be easier to just walk away, Ed and Herb Brunton said.

But they believe no other job would be as rewarding as running their family farm.

“The hardest part is when you wake up at three in the morning, and you go home at eight o'clock at night,” Herb Brunton said. “But then there's this pride or connection to the place that you've lived in for 54 years. And the pressure that you’re gonna let your ancestors down if you sell it all. That's pretty much the same here.”

Sixteen dairy cows died in the fire. Herb and Ed Brunton didn’t want to talk about the deaths; the pain of losing them still stings.

Advertise with us

Instead, they recalled how they and others refused to give up on the 84 cows they could save. They didn’t leave the barn until the ceiling started to cave in, the brothers said.

“We got the cows sorted out and taken where they needed to go,” Ed Brunton said. “And then after that, we went over to the Craig Farm where there was a whole other crew of people working to get that set up.

“I didn't get home until like 1:30 in the morning. And then at 4:30 we woke up and did it again.”

Ciara McEneany: cmceneany@post-gazette.com