A state Superior Court decision on Monday upheld a permanent injunction issued last year against striking Pittsburgh Post-Gazette workers picketing a Butler printing plant, but sent the case back to a lower court to modify certain stipulations that were “overly restrictive.”
The higher court found that the Butler County Court of Common Pleas injunction issued in October 2022 needed changes to ensure the constitutional rights of the picketers.
“The modified permanent injunction must be sufficient to stop violent behavior and deter appellants from blocking the rear fenced gate while not infringing upon appellants’ First Amendment right to peacefully picket in public spaces,” according to the ruling.
After several Post-Gazette unions went on strike in the fall of 2022, the Pittsburgh newspaper contracted with the Butler Eagle to print its Thursday and Sunday editions. On Oct. 22, 2022, picketers blocked delivery vans from leaving the Butler plant and threw objects at the vehicles, breaking glass and pounding on the vans with their fists, according to court documents.
The Superior Court decision issued Monday found that the strikers’ conduct constituted a seizure of property. “The issue is not how many bodies form the picket line, but if there is interference with the ingress and egress of a plaintiff’s property,” the court found. “The control of the entrances is control of the plant.”
In issuing the injunction last year, the Butler County Court strictly limited the number of picketers to 10 and prohibited picketing at a rear fenced gate area on West Wayne Street and on a public sidewalk on the south side of the street. The restrictions on the location and number of picketers were “overly broad,” the higher court found.
Read More
In March, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court had put a stay on the ban against mass picketing by Post-Gazette strikers at the Butler Eagle until the union’s appeal to the state Superior Court was resolved.
Members of five Post-Gazette unions walked off the job in October 2022 after working without a contract since 2017. Dozens of reporters, photographers and other newsroom employees who were members of the Pittsburgh Newspaper Guild joined the picket line to protest a switch to a higher cost health insurance plan.
The walkout deeply divided newsroom staff. About 100 reporters, copyeditors and other newsroom employees have continued to put out the print and online editions of the newspaper, with about 35 others still on the picket line.
Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.