An Allegheny County Common Pleas Court judge has scheduled two days of hearings in June on a petition by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette to end picketing on private property as conflicts at newspaper distribution centers escalate and the work stoppage enters its seventh month.
Judge Mary C. McGinley set hearings for June 1 and 2 on the Post-Gazette’s request for a permanent injunction against picketing on private property by members of five labor unions who walked off the job in October over a switch to a more expensive health insurance plan. The order follows the submission of briefs by company and union attorneys that argued for and against the legality of picketing on private property.
“The court concludes that there may be circumstances where picketing may occur on private property and there may be circumstances where picketing may not occur on private property,” Judge McGinley wrote. “The requisite analysis is fact-specific and dependent on the circumstances presented by each unique case.”
Picketing at Gateway View Plaza on the South Side and other newspaper distribution centers has sparked scuffles with picketers and non-union workers and police. On Wednesday, the company said, 19 police cruisers responded to the West Carson Street depot after strikers tried to prevent a delivery truck from entering the terminal.
City public safety spokeswoman Amanda Mueller said Thursday that the city was “currently in the process of reviewing all video footage and other resources available to us in order to ensure a complete assessment of events.” There were no arrests.
Pittsburgh’s newspaper strike, the industry's longest in decades, affects newsroom, printing and other employees who belong to one of five unions. More than 60 reporters, copy editors and designers are not participating in the strike and continue to produce the newspaper’s digital and print editions along with about 20 newsroom managers. Just under 40 newsroom employees are part of the walkout.
Read More
In February, Post-Gazette attorneys filed for a court injunction to stop strikers from entering Gateway View Plaza and attempting to interfere with independent drivers and other workers. The unions have argued in court filings that they have a “clearly protected” right to picket at the South Side terminal, citing the National Labor Relations Law of 1935.
“This case involves striking employees of the Post-Gazette picketing in common parking spaces and driveways used by the Post-Gazette,” the unions wrote in a court filing. “Picketing in such areas is clearly protected under Section 7 of the NLRB, even though such areas may be ‘private property.’”
Union officials did not respond to a request for comment on Friday.
The Post-Gazette said the unions were applying a federal labor law to a matter that rightfully belongs in state court. “State courts and law enforcement authorities are responsible for keeping the peace and enforcing state law, like trespassing,” the newspaper’s attorneys wrote.
Veteran labor attorney Joe Pass from the firm of Jubelirer, Pass & Intrieri P.C. is representing the unions; Brian M. Hentosz from Littler Mendelson P.C. is representing the newspaper.
Negotiations between the company and its unions have continued but neither side has reported significant progress.
In January, an administrative law judge for the National Labor Relations Board issued a ruling that Post-Gazette management had bargained in bad faith since 2019 with the union representing newsroom employees. The company has appealed the decision.
Rising picket line tensions are to be expected in a strike that has lasted six months, said Ilene A. DeVault, professor of labor history at Cornell University.
“Strikers are risking everything, so the longer the strike goes, the uglier it gets on the picket line,” she said. “It will take a long time to overcome the resentments that have developed.”
Recent strikes at media outlets, such as ones at the New York Times and Hearst Magazines, were short-lived, which may benefit strikers, Ms. DeVault said.
Walkouts that occur without majority employee support can struggle, she said.
“The fact is if the union has strength and support and it’s a fast strike that immediately affects the bottom line of the business — that’s a much better scenario for workers than if the strike drags on and on and on,” she said. “That’s pretty problematic.”
In the meantime, Post-Gazette officials believe picket line clashes have been increasing as strikers have been joined by union activists from outside Pittsburgh.
Post-Gazette Director of Operations Robert Weber said the number of pickets and disruptions have been increasing since the start of April when 35 strikers and supporters showed up at a distribution center in Monroeville. There, picketers lined up in front of wooden pallets that had been piled up to block a delivery truck.
“We were forced to drop the load in the middle of the chaos,” he said. “They were banging on delivery cars. The cops couldn’t control it anymore.
“It had just gotten out of hand. It’s getting worse.”
In recounting the confrontation, an anonymous contributor to the online news platform Filler Distro who joined Post-Gazette union members in the protest, said the response by about eight police officers to the scene was a “deterrent to success.”
Filler Distro publishes anarchist-supporting authors, but is not affiliated with any organization mentioned on the site.
“Ultimately, police unions shouldn’t be accepted in the labor movement,” the Filler Distro author wrote. “Even in this tame situation, they were the primary deterrent to success and potential success. Outnumbering them is still probably the safest route.”
Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.