For financial adviser Matt Helfrich, rising costs have rekindled a conversation he last had with his clients two years ago when the stock market sold off in response to the COVID-19 outbreak.

Mr. Helfrich, president of Waldron Private Wealth in Bridgeville, is encouraging individuals with traditional IRAs to convert at least a portion of those accounts to Roth IRAs in order to take advantage of the opportunity to pay a reduced tax on stocks that have fallen in value. That strategy, he said, could be the right move for retirement savers who want be able to make tax-free withdrawals from their IRAs going forward.

This interview has been edited for space and clarity.

PG: Why is a broad stock market decline to best time to do a Roth IRA conversion?

Advertise with us

A: Let’s say your IRA balance was $100,000 and it dropped to $80,000. If you convert that IRA to a Roth IRA you are now paying tax on $80,000. If your tax rate is 25%, that’s $20,000. You pay the tax, and now when that $80,000 goes back to $100,000 or $120,000, that’s all now tax free. You have in essence a $20,000 hurdle because that’s the tax that you paid to get a Roth IRA. Now, any growth over $20,000 is going to put you in a better financial position.

PG: If there’s no such thing as a free lunch, what are the disadvantages that come with doing the Roth IRA conversion?

A: The disadvantage of that strategy is your IRA never recovers its value before you have to start pulling money out. Or you need to pull money out of that Roth IRA before age 59½.

PG: What if you don’t have cash outside of the retirement account to pay the tax due on the Roth IRA conversion? Can you pay it from money within the retirement account?

A: Not unless you are over 59½. In order for it to be the most optimal scenario, you should be paying the tax with money outside your IRA. If you’re over 59½, you can take it out without any penalty. But the most optimal way to do it is to use money outside your IRA. You want to preserve that money in the Roth IRA so that it can keep growing tax-free.

Advertise with us

PG: Is there an age when it’s not beneficial to do the Roth conversion or when an investor is less likely to reap the benefits of a conversion?

A: I would say it’s not so much a function of age but a function of needing to pull the money out. If you’re 75 and healthy, you can still do Roth conversions if you’re 75 and healthy. The idea is you’ve just got to live long enough and be in a financial position where you’re not pulling the money out before the account value rebounds.

PG: Does this only work with an IRA? What about people who have a 401k?

A: You can roll your 401k into an IRA and convert it. Every company has different rules. But it usually only works if you’re not at the company any longer. It’s most optimal if you’re retired or you have an old 401k from your prior company that’s just sitting there. That’s where this is really useful.

If you are actively employed at your company right now it will likely be pretty tough to do it. It all depends on what the plan documents allow you to do.

Advertise with us

PG: How often can you use the Roth conversion strategy? If somebody already did a conversion in 2020, what’s left for them to do now?

A: They may not have converted the whole amount. You don’t have to convert the entire account. They may have only converted a portion of their IRA or 401k in 2020. You can convert half of it now and half of it later. In other words, if you own 100 shares of Apple stock in an IRA, you could convert 50 shares.

You can actually limit the Roth conversion to an amount you are able to pay taxes on out-of-pocket. When the money is in a traditional IRA, the growth is not tax-free. It’s tax-deferred. You are eventually going to have to pay the tax when you pull the money out. With a Roth conversion, you in essence are paying all of the tax now versus over time later.

Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com