Most of Pennsylvania’s state employees received a raise in 2020, even if it was fairly modest, although some workers didn’t see any bump in pay.
Some of those increases were approved before the emergence of the coronavirus pandemic. For Senate staffers, however, it was the extra workload from the pandemic that made their bosses feel they were deserving of a pay increase when their work anniversary rolls around.
But some state workers didn’t get any raise this year. Those who didn’t get a pay increase will have some company in 2021.
Next year, state lawmakers, judges and top executive branch officials will not be receiving a raise, courtesy of Act 79. That legislation, sponsored by Rep. Frank Ryan, R-Lebanon County, paused the automatic cost-of-living adjustment lawmakers typically receive on Dec. 1. Judges and top executive branch officials would have seen their raise (often dubbed a “COLA”) kick in on Jan. 1.
Among those in the commonwealth’s workforce that didn’t get a raise this year were management and non-unionized employees at the Pennsylvania Treasury Department and staffers in the state House of Representatives. Both the House Republican and Democratic caucuses held off on raises this year.
Among those in the commonwealth’s workforce that didn’t get a raise this year were management and non-unionized employees at the Pennsylvania Treasury Department and staffers in the state House of Representatives. Both the House Republican and Democratic caucuses held off on raises this year.
Read More
“During a time of significant budgetary pressure, Treasury is committed to focusing resources on maintaining service to the commonwealth without interruption,” said Treasury spokeswoman Ashley Matthews, explaining the rationale behind the decision to hold off on raises to management employees.
A spokesman for House Speaker Bryan Cutler, R-Lancaster County, said the decision to hold off on granting raises to GOP staffers was not made lightly but was necessary.
“Every industry, every person really in Pennsylvania had to make a sacrifice in some way as a result of the pandemic and pandemic response,” said Mike Straub, a spokesman for Cutler. “So when you take a look at state revenues and where things stand, it was a fairly easy decision to recognize that this is not the year where there’s a lot of extra money in the coffers to provide even regular pay increases and that’s where the decision came from.”
House Democratic caucus spokesman Bill Patton also said a pay freeze couldn’t be avoided.
“While the staff worked harder than ever before, Democratic leaders could not grant a cost-of-living raise as has been done occasionally in other years,” Patton said. “The caucus lacked the money to broadly raise pay.”
It might have been easier for employees affected by those decisions to accept their pay freeze had others around them not received one. But state employees represented by unions received their contractually obligated raises. Most of them received a 2.25% raise in April and a 2% hike in October.
The nearly 14,000 management and non-unionized workers who serve under Gov. Tom Wolf’s jurisdiction also received raises of the same size and at the same time as unionized employees, said Dan Egan, a spokesman for the governor’s Office of Administration.
“We are very cognizant of the challenges that pay disparity [between unionized and non-represented employees] created in the past with retention and management, and we are maintaining a pay structure to avoid similar challenges in the future,” Egan said.
At Treasury, one management employee said what made the pay freeze there difficult to swallow was seeing raises being given to their non-represented counterparts at the other statewide row offices.
Employees in the Attorney General’s office received a 3% across-the-board raise in January. In the Auditor General’s office, non-represented employees were given a 3.25% lump sum payment in July paychecks to avoid having those increases built into employee’s base pay, as well as preventing it from impacting future pension payments and payroll, said spokesman Gary Miller.
In both of those instances, the decision to grant those pay bumps was made prior to the March onset of the pandemic that wreaked havoc with the state’s economy due to governor-ordered business shutdowns for health and safety reasons.
However, the Senate was in the midst of the pandemic when the decision to grant raises for staffers. Both the Senate Republican and Democratic caucuses approved giving their staffers a raise of less than on their work anniversary over the next 12 months, starting this past July 1.
Senate Democratic Leader Jay Costa of Allegheny County said he felt staffers earned a raise given the work they put in to transition all of the services of the Senate to a remote work setting without interruption – learning how to conduct meetings and hearings remotely to drafting bills, including one for a $4 billion PA CARES 21 COVID-relief package the Democrats proposed, while working from home.
In addition, he said they took on “massive increases in workload” to help constituents process unemployment compensation claims, applications for assistance with energy bills, food stamp applications, and direct small business owners to programs available to assist them.
Senate GOP spokeswoman Jenn Kocher said the Republican caucus wanted to recognize the hard of staffers with modest bumps in pay.
“The Senate offices remained open throughout the pandemic and were inundated with calls from constituents needing assistance,” Kocher said. “We also continued with remote Senate sessions. We felt it was appropriate to provide minimal raises on anniversary dates to show appreciation for the efforts made to continue to serve Pennsylvanians under extraordinary circumstances.”
Ryan, who authored the pay freeze law, said he recognizes how hard some state and legislative employees have worked in 2020 and knows some are feeling burned out with no pay raise to reward them. He wishes there could be a way to recognize their efforts, but at the same time, Ryan said Pennsylvanians have to realize the dire straits of the state’s financial condition.
“We have a $5 billion budget gap that we have to make up and there are people struggling mercilessly,” he said. “But I know there are significant number of state workers that are working so hard so I do empathize with them.”



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.