Chocolate rolls off the factory lines by the tons each year at Betsy Ann Chocolates, but owner Jim Paras keeps his eye on the details.
He knows when someone eats one of his chocolate truffles or cordial cherries they will base their opinion of the whole company on that one piece.
“Usually, the first one is going to leave a lasting impression,” he said. “So we have to make every piece be as good as it can be.”
That can be a tall order, especially with a perishable product. Not to mention keeping all those ingredients in balance and a lot of other balls in the air. Mr. Paras will tell you the candymaking business may be sweet, but it’s not easy.
In the 52 years since Jim Paras’ parents — Harry and Catherine Paras — took over the West View candy factory from founder and namesake Betsy Ann Helsel in 1967, the company has seen its shares of ups and downs.
Read More

In the early 2000s, the company operated 14 Betsy Ann retail locations spread out as far as Cleveland, although most stores were clustered in Downtown, North Hills, South Hills, Cranberry, Century III Mall and Monroeville.
Then, there was a period around 2008 when the company was literally in the dark.
Business had been booming in the 1990s. The company strategically located its retail stores outside several Kaufmann’s department stores in Downtown and various mall locations to take advantage of the considerable foot traffic.
It was a perfect location until Kaufmann’s was bought out by Macy’s in 2006 and subsequently shut down. The Mall at Robinson decided to save money on electricity by shutting off the lights at that end of the mall.
“I had my employees calling me saying, ‘Hey, we’re afraid to work down here,’” said Mr. Paras, 61.
The company has had to reinvent itself a few times. In addition to the changing department store ownership, there was a serious slowdown in corporate holiday spending following the terrorist attacks in September 2001. That market never fully recovered.
Today, Betsy Ann Chocolates runs two retail stores — one on the first floor of its West View factory and one on Route 8 at Shopper’s Plaza in Hampton. But the lion’s share of the business comes from wholesale agreements with grocery chains such as Giant Eagle and Sam’s Club. Online sales are also picking up.
Although the company had annual revenues of $3.1 million in 2018 thanks to a lucrative deal to place its products in 17 Sam’s Club stores across the region, revenues actually fell from $3.3 million the previous year as the company spent money on revamped its facilities and production processes.
‘A very serious businesswoman’
The Betsy Ann Chocolates story began in 1949. The founder began making candy in her home using skills she learned working at Korinis Confectioners on the North Side.
As the business expanded, two executives from Joseph Horne Co. offered to sell her chocolates in their store under the Joseph Horne name. Horne’s candy business would later become one of the largest among department stores in the country.
In 1961, Betsy Ann Helsel relocated her business to West View. She lived above the candy store and continued to work until she broke her hip falling down steps that led from the office to the store. She never fully recovered and on April 1, 1967, she sold the business to the Paras family.
Harry J. Paras had been a former baker for Fox Bakery in East Liberty. Jim Paras said he was about 10 years old when his dad bought the company and began training with Ms. Helsel.
“To be honest with you, she wasn’t too keen on kids in the factory,” he said. “She was very disciplined. She wasn’t mean or anything. It’s just that she felt the factory was not a place for children. It was business. She was a very serious businesswoman.”
Jim Paras and his two brothers started working on Saturdays in the fall and summer.
As a 12-year-old boy, he remembered earning $5 a day. Eight hours on a chocolate assembly line may sound like paradise, but for a youngster barely tall enough to see over the conveyor belt, it could be tough on the back.
After more than five decades, Betsy Ann Chocolates is still a family affair. Jim Para’s wife, Karen; his brother Bob; his daughter Elizabeth; and son David all work for the company. His daughter Emily attends Kent State University in Ohio, but works when she is home. His father Harry, 92, and his mother Catherine, 89, are retired.
The company employs about 40 workers.
‘They closed the Kaufmann’s’
By the time Jim Paras began managing the business in 1988, the big Downtown department store era was coming to an end. Horne’s, Gimbels and Kaufmann’s had been Pittsburgh’s three major Downtown stores. As they reached into suburban malls, Betsy Ann had expanded along with them.
That year a buying group for independent department stores called Associated Dry Goods — which Horne’s was a part of — was bought out. The new owners didn’t want to carry candy in the stores because candy departments were a lot of work.
“I had to convince my father that we needed to make some big changes and he wasn’t ready for any big changes,” Jim Paras said. “But the changes were already on us. Eventually, he agreed and we started to open our own retail stores.”
Inside Horne’s, the company had sold its candy under Horne’s name. After opening their own stores, they rebranded as “Betsy Ann.” At its highest point in the early 2000s, the company operated 14 independent store locations.
“What happened was 9/11 was a big event for us,” Jim Paras said. “And I never thought it would be. I remember talking to people and thinking the candy business has always been solid and it would never change.”
A different attitude toward spending evolved.
“That Christmas it became almost a kind of mantra, especially with bigger companies, that nobody’s buying Christmas gifts this year because 9/11 happened and it’s not appropriate to celebrate after such a horrible event,” he recalled.
After skipping that holiday season, companies started eliminating chocolate gifts from future holiday budgets.
Then department stores continued to consolidate. Lazarus department store had bought Horne’s in 1994. Then Macy’s bought Lazarus in the early 2000s. Macy’s then bought Kaufmann’s. Macy’s ended up owning Kaufmann’s and Lazarus.
Macy’s didn’t need two stores in the malls. “Here we were thinking they were never going to close Kaufmann’s,” Jim Paras said. “So what stores did they close? They closed the Kaufmann’s.”
Mr. Paras said he was able to negotiate his way out of three “monster” 10-year leases as best he could.
A comeback
The first event that turned things around occurred around the fall of 2009. Macy’s invited the company to set up shops inside its Pittsburgh-area stores.
Macy’s ended its partnership with Betsy Ann Chocolatesin 2016, but by then, the chocolate company had reached a major deal with Sam’s Club.
When Betsy Ann started sending product to a local Sam’s Club, the store manager wanted to promote it and sales were robust. But when they visited other clubs more than 100 miles away from Pittsburgh, the managers weren’t so excited about the unfamiliar brand.
“You might find that they have the product sitting up in the rafters,” Jim Paras said. “They are not selling anything and we have to eat what they don’t sell. So once we learned a bit, we knew we had to be careful about expanding too quickly because this could really come back to bite you.”
Mr. Paras said he is fine with Betsy Ann Chocolates’ slow and steady growth for the time being.
“We are getting bigger and bigger,” he said. “If you meet somebody in this business, they are probably hardworking people. It’s not an easy business. It’s a nice business, but there is a lot of work involved.”
Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.