U.S. steel industry executives and the head of the United Steelworkers union sat shoulder-to-shoulder on Wednesday to urge the Trump administration to keep U.S. tariffs on Chinese imports of steel.
The tariffs, imposed one year ago in a move tied to national security concerns, have boosted demand for American-produced steel, leading to a flood of investment and job creation at mills across the country — a “renaissance” in the words of U.S. Steel CEO David B. Burritt.
Yet sharp disagreement divided Mr. Burritt and Leo Gerard, president of the United Steelworkers, on whether the 25 percent steel tariffs should continue to apply to imports from Canada — the United States’ closest trading partner — and from Mexico.
“Even our best allies and their steel producers have been found to dump and subsidize steel imports into the USA, and they can be conduits for foreign steel from China, Russia and elsewhere,” Mr. Burritt told a Congressional panel in Washington, D.C.
“If the Section 232 doesn’t apply everywhere, it’s nowhere,” Mr. Burritt added, arguing that Chinese steel will continue to slip into the United States through “border leaks” with Canada and Mexico.
That prompted a retort from Mr. Gerard, whose union represents more than 9,000 steelworkers in Canada. Steel trade between the U.S. and Canada has long been balanced, he said, and he pointed to an agreement for the two countries to share steel supplies in times of war.
Read More
Canadian steel mills “are not getting subsidized by anybody,” Mr. Gerard said. “As we have said since day one, they should not have been applied to Canada, which has a truly unique defense, intelligence, and economic relationship with the U.S.”
That debate now threatens to derail an updated trade deal with Canada and Mexico — the rewrite of the North American Free Trade Agreement, or NAFTA, originally passed in 1992.
The new North American trade pact, called the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement, or USMCA, was signed by officials of all three countries on Nov. 30 after months of contentious trade talks. The renegotiation was prompted by President Donald Trump’s call to terminate or improve trade deals, taking particular aim at NAFTA, which he has called “the worst trade deal ever made.”
But the deal has hit a roadblock in Congress, which must ratify the agreement to put it into effect.
Democrats, who took control the U.S. House of Representatives in January, have questioned the USMCA’s toughness on labor protections and environmental standards and have argued some intellectual property provisions could lock in high prescription drug prices.
Add steel tariffs to the list of questions about the trade pact — though the ideological divide is less clear.
Much of Wednesday’s hearing, called by the Congressional Steel Caucus chaired by Rep. Conor Lamb, D-Mt. Lebanon, focused on the need to keep the tariffs on Chinese steel in place.
Testimony was unified from steel and manufacturing industry executives representing Nucor Corp., ArcelorMittal USA, Commercial Metals Co. and Zekelman Industries.
Lawmakers from both parties seemed to either back tariffs on Canada or criticize the trade deal as insufficient.
“The focus of this committee, I believe, should be our U.S. workers,” Rep. Mike Bost, R-Ill., cutting off Mr. Gerard.
Rep. Marcy Kaptur, D-Ohio, asked Mr. Gerard about wage protections for workers in Mexico and did not get an answer that satisfied her.
“That’s what’s really going on with these trade deals: It’s an open door to a diminished standard of living,” she said.
Growing tensions
Calls to remove the tariffs on Canada have been growing.
The tariffs have been a dark stain on the tone of U.S.-Canada relations that has bled into efforts to form other partnerships, said Phyllis Yaffe, Canada’s consul general, in an interview last week.
Ms. Yaffe traveled to Pittsburgh with two Canadian tech companies, Montreal-based Element AI and MindBridge, to meet with Carnegie Mellon University, Google and elected officials to discuss partnerships in the field of artificial intelligence.
Ms. Yaffe said the tariffs have effectively halted the trade deal and that has broad implications for Pennsylvania, where 360,000 jobs statewide depend on trade with Canada.
“Canadians would think we were wrong to ratify the agreement while the tariffs are still there,” she said. “First, we’d like to see the tariffs go away and then we’d like to see all three countries ratify it and get back to the trade that has been working for all three countries.
“The tariffs were supposed to go away the day we all signed the agreement,” she added. “We are not a national security threat.”
Mr. Burritt at U.S. Steel seemed to acknowledge that point. While the biggest culprit is China, he said, the tariffs on U.S. allies serve as an incentive to form a coalition to align trade policies as a shield.
The tariffs are “a little bit of a carrot and a little bit of a stick,” he said. “That’s what the tariffs are doing. It’s bringing people together to come up with a solution.”
Quotas instead of tariffs?
Steel industry executives have floated suggestions for a different type of trade barrier, apparently as a concession to Canada and Mexico.
In a statement following the hearing, John Brett, president and CEO of ArcelorMittal USA, said he would support ending the tariffs and imposing quotas — replacing the 25 percent border tax with a cap on the amount of imported steel over a given period of time.
And that should happen, Mr. Brett said, only with verification that all steel exported to the United States is melted and poured at steel mills in Canada and Mexico.
Mr. Burritt said he would be open to a “hard quota” instead of a tariff on Canada and Mexico.
But it is far from clear that tariff critics would be any more amenable to quotas.
In November, a top oil and gas industry official wrote in The Hill that quotas would be “far more damaging” than tariffs.
“The oil and gas industry relies on Mexico and Canada to supply steel products that many mills in the United States either simply don’t manufacture because the market is too small or can’t supply at a scale that meets today’s demand,” wrote Ed Longanecker, president of the Texas Independent Producers & Royalty Owners Association, a trade group with 3,000 members in Texas.
“Projects increasingly face the risk of grinding to a halt while steel imports sit in warehouses waiting for the quota to open,” he wrote.
Pressure to remove the tariffs — seen in tens of thousands of exemption requests filed by American companies that rely on imported steel — is up against an expectation that the steel industry could hit another downturn.
Mr. Gerard said he thinks the steel industry is still in recovery, with room to nearly double annual production from 85 million tons today to 150 million tons.
Meanwhile, a rapid expansion of American steel mills and a wave of investment is expected to push down prices and create long-term competition for the Pittsburgh steel company.
Mr. Burritt reminded lawmakers it was only three years ago that the American steel industry was forced to layoff thousands of steelworkers.
“The U.S. steel industry is still vulnerable,” Mr. Burritt said. “Now is not the time to blink.”
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.