A federal judge has reduced a $3 million jury award to a former PPG scientist who sued the company for gender discrimination.
In an order handed down Monday, U.S. District Judge Bill Wilson cut the original award for former PPG employee Carol Knox to $2.2 million, saying that portions of the sum resulted in a “windfall.”
Her attorney said he is weighing whether to appeal.
“We respectfully disagree with the court's reduction of the amount awarded by the jury and are presently evaluating whether to challenge it on appeal,” said Bruce Fox, who represents Ms. Knox.
A jury in October awarded $2.97 million to Ms. Knox, who worked as a senior research scientist and project leader at PPG’s Monroeville business and technology center for 23 years.
In her lawsuit and during a four-day trial, Ms. Knox said her supervisor at PPG didn’t want to work with women and the company in 2013 found a reason to fire her that was unrelated to her job performance.
Read More
The jury’s award included $1.5 million in compensatory damages, $478,585 in back pay, and $993,495 in front pay.
Front pay is awarded when courts decide victims of employment discrimination will lose future earnings because they cannot return to the jobs where they experienced bias.
Judge Wilson cut Ms. Knox’s front pay award by 80 percent, to approximately $198,700, saying, “Front pay is intended to get you back on your feet, not provide a windfall.”
“Front pay is appropriate in this case but the jury’s advisory award of 10 years of front pay is too generous,” the judge’s order said. “Two years is appropriate in this case.”
After being fired by PPG, Ms. Knox found a job at Covestro, a German company with North American headquarters in Robinson.
Her salary was lower and she was not on a management track.
The judge said Ms. Knox’s testimony “didn’t reflect that she is looking very hard” for a higher-paying position.
“But, if chemist positions are limited, that’s not her fault,” the judge’s order said.
The front pay award includes wages, retirement benefits and an allowance for taxes on the lump sum award.
Though he agreed with the jury’s back pay award, Judge Wilson cut the interest paid on that amount to $30,400 from $45,665.
A gap between her firing in 2013 and when she filed the lawsuit in 2015 warranted calculating the interest at a lower rate and reducing it by 30 percent, the judge said.
Ms. Knox also is seeking $1.75 million in attorneys fees and other costs.
Joyce Gannon: jgannon@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1580.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.