A federal jury Thursday ordered PPG to pay nearly $3 million to a woman scientist who claimed she was fired after 23 years with the company because of gender discrimination.
Carol Knox, a former senior research scientist and project leader for PPG, sued the Pittsburgh coatings giant in 2015 claiming her supervisor didn’t want to work with women and came up with a reason to oust her that was unrelated to her work performance.
PPG claimed Ms. Knox’s termination had nothing to do with her sex.
The company said she was fired in 2013 because of inconsistent statements she made about an email on her computer.
A jury of seven men and five women rendered the verdict after a four-day trial in U.S. District Court in Pittsburgh. Several times during the trial, U.S. District Judge Bill Wilson urged attorneys for PPG and Ms. Knox to settle the case.
The $2.97 million that the jury awarded to Ms. Knox includes about $1.5 million in economic damages and the rest for emotional distress.
Read More
“I think the jury reacted to very harsh treatment of a distinguished female scientist and wanted to send a message that would be heard,” said Ms. Knox’s attorney, Bruce Fox.
In a statement later Thursday, the company said: "PPG is committed to fostering a diverse and inclusive workplace. We have a strong commitment to equal employment opportunity, and we do not make employment or advancement decisions based on gender, race, age, or any other legally protected status. We are disappointed with the outcome and we are considering our options for appeal."
Ms. Knox, who was based at PPG’s business and technology center in Monroeville, claimed a manager, Truman Wilt, discriminated against her repeatedly because she was a woman.
When Mr. Wilt became her supervisor in 2010, Ms. Knox said, he acknowledged he “was uncomfortable around women” and that “women were better suited in business” than working on the technical side of the company.
Among remarks Mr. Wilt made while she worked for him, Ms. Knox said, was that “all women are tree-hugging liberals.”
He referred to a work assignment staffed by women as “the girls project,” Ms. Knox said.
He assigned her to what her suit called “innocuous administrative teams,” such as the United Way charity, while her male colleagues were appointed to teams involving technology and trends.
Earlier this week, Ms. Knox testified that while her performance reviews “tended to be above average” before Mr. Wilt became her boss, he gave her average reviews and would not assist her in taking steps to advance.
In his closing argument Thursday, Mr. Fox said Mr. Wilt “wanted [Ms. Knox] out of there but couldn’t do it in a legitimate way” because of her excellent performance record.
He wanted to replace her with a man who was “part of the old boys club,” Mr. Fox said.
After PPG fired her, Ms. Knox was hired by Bayer MaterialScience. That operation has since spun out from Bayer Corp. as an independent business called Covestro and has its North American headquarters in Robinson.
At her current position, Ms. Knox testified she makes about half the salary that she earned at PPG and she is not on a management track as she had been at PPG.
The termination “not only took my career away, it destroyed my name and I no longer have confidence to be a manager again at that level,” she said. “It just kills your confidence and self-esteem.”
The email that PPG claimed led to her dismissal contained photographs of a current PPG employee and a former employee who were alleged to be having an inappropriate romantic affair.
In 2010, the company had asked Ms. Knox to take notes and compile information about the two individuals. It was trying to determine if their relationship violated company policy.
At the time, one of the individuals reported to Ms. Knox.
In July 2013, the week before she was fired, Ms. Knox was on vacation with her family in Michigan when she received the email from an anonymous sender.
She forwarded it to Mr. Wilt and someone in the human relations department.
When she returned from vacation, she was called into a meeting and told if she couldn’t explain who sent the email she would be fired immediately.
Ms. Knox said she didn’t know the source. She was dismissed that day.
“There was no evidence PPG made any decision based on Carol’s sex,” Ted Schroeder, the company’s attorney, said in his closing statement.
PPG “would’ve made the same decision if she was a man,” Mr. Schroeder said.
Joyce Gannon: jgannon@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1580.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.