Given the escalation in executive compensation over the past several decades, the apparent rule of thumb in corporate board rooms seems to be that paying CEOs too much means not paying them enough.
Mutual fund managers and other large institutional investors apparently are fine with that.
Since 2011, they and other investors have been voting on the compensation plans of companies in their portfolios. While the vote is advisory — companies are not obligated to do anything if their pay plans are voted down — the referendum can send a powerful message.
Last year, shareholders supported pay plans by margins of over 95 percent in roughly half of the votes analyzed by Equilar, a Redwood City, Calif., firm that advises companies on pay, governance and related issues. Shareholders gave less than 50 percent approval to only five of the 500 largest U.S. companies, Equilar reported.
This year, shareholders have shot down pay plans at only about 2 percent of the companies analyzed by Semler Brossy, a Los Angeles-based compensation consultant.
Mutual funds exhibit a pronounced reluctance to protest executive pay, according to As You Sow. Each year, the shareholder advocacy group identifies the country’s 100 most overpaid CEOs. Most of their pay is ritually approved by shareholders.
Read More
“The rubber-stamping trend continues, even with evidence showing persistent underperformance of the highest-paid CEOs,” said Rosanna Landis Weaver, who oversees the organization’s annual pay report.
As You Sow says the average company uses about 10,000 words to justify why it pays its top executives as much as it does.
Mutual funds apparently are accepting the tortured prose as fact, although perhaps not quite as eagerly as they have in the past. Four years ago, four large mutual fund companies voted against 30 percent of the companies supporting As You Sow’s most overpaid CEOs. Last year, 12 mutual fund companies voted down 30 percent of them.
Fidelity and Vanguard, the two largest mutual fund operators, only voted against 12 percent of the 100 most overpaid CEOs, the organization said. Another large mutual fund family, Blackrock, voted down a mere 11 percent of them.
The two biggest firms that advise institutional investors on how to vote on pay and other shareholder issues are only a little more skeptical. Institutional Shareholder Services recommended no votes for 38 of As You Sow’s most overpaid CEOs while Glass Lewis opposed 42 percent.
As You Sow’s list is based on total shareholder return and how many no votes a company’s pay plan receives.
Oracle co-CEOs Safra Catz and Mark Hurd were the most overpaid at $82 million combined. They were followed by the $33 million Robert Kotick earned at Activision Blizzard, the company that develops Call of Duty, Candy Crush and other interactive entertainment.
No Pittsburgh-based companies made the roster.
But Mylan CEO Heather Bresch topped As You Sow’s list of CEOs from companies whose pay packages received the least support from shareholders last year. Only 17 percent of the drug maker’s shareholders supported the pay plan of the company, which has its administrative offices in Cecil. ConocoPhillips and CEO Ryan Lance finished second, with shareholders offering 32 percent support.
It might surprise General Electric shareholders that As You Sow ranked former CEO Jeffrey Immelt as only the 70th most overpaid chief executive. Of course, 89 percent of investors supported the troubled conglomerate’s pay plan at GE’s April 2017 shareholder meeting.
Since then, GE has: announced a $10 billion fourth quarter loss; cut its dividend in half; revealed $11 billion plans to sell its transportation business to Wilmerding-based Wabtec; and disclosed that its accounting practices are being investigated by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission.
GE shares have lost about half of their value since the 2017 pay vote.
That’s enough to make a shareholder wonder whether the $222 million GE paid Mr. Immelt between 2007 and 2017 was just a little bit too much.
How often do such thoughts cross the minds of institutional investors? If they ever do, it’s usually only after the havoc has been wreaked. Institutional investors’ real-time skepticism over CEO pay is increasing at a glacial pace. That’s nothing to cheer about for those who believe CEO talent is overpriced and something needs to be done about it.
Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.