For 22 years, Deena Khatiwoda worked with numbers.
From third grade, when he arrived in Nepal as a Bhutanese refugee fleeing persecution, until he got his master’s degree, Mr. Khatiwoda followed a career path into accounting, economics and marketing. He worked as an accountant and taught economics and marketing — all while living as a second-class citizen in Nepal.
But his experience mattered little when he landed in Pittsburgh in 2014, after the U.S. began accepting Bhutanese refugees for permanent resettlement. By U.S. law, he had to find a job within three months before losing financial assistance.
“We started finding some entry-level jobs — only entry-level,” said Mr. Khatiwoda, 34, of Whitehall, who now works as a freelance translator and part-time as a caregiver.
“We know that USA stands for You Start Again,” he laughed.
While resettlement organizations handle the basics of integrating refugees and immigrants into a community — finding the newcomers a home, connecting them to government services and employers who will hire them right away — the haste of that process forces many who arrive here as mid-career professionals to settle for underemployment.
Of nearly 7.8 million immigrants with college degrees in the United States, about 2 million are relegated to low-skilled jobs or are unable to find work, according to a 2016 study from the Washington, D.C.-based Migration Policy Institute.
That study estimated that college-educated immigrants employed in low-skilled work lose $39 billion in wages and the government misses out on more than $10 billion in taxes.
The Pittsburgh region is particularly vulnerable. At the same time businesses complain about a workforce shortage in the next decade, waves of highly-educated migrants populate the region, according to five-year averages compiled by the U.S. Census Bureau.
Roughly 70,000 foreign-born residents reside in Allegheny County, including a large group of Bhutanese refugees from Nepal who have settled in the South Hills.
A recent initiative from Pennsylvania Women Work, a Downtown-based nonprofit, aims to get foreign-born workers back into the careers they built in their home countries.
Pennsylvania Women Work, with funding from an anonymous donor set up by The Pittsburgh Foundation, has gathered 25 clients since last September — helping them to verify their degrees and credentials, and to improve their resumes and interview skills.
“Right now, the clients are at least getting through those application systems and getting interviews,” said Sandra Marsh-McClain, the group’s program manager for RISE, or Refugee and Immigrant Services for Employment.
“Before, most of the clients that I have will tell you they have applied to anywhere from 50 to 200 jobs and received nothing.”
The program aims to combat “brain waste,” an economic drain that occurs when foreign-born workers take jobs they are overqualified for. About 61 percent of all foreign-born residents have educational attainment of a bachelor’s degree or more, compared with 38 percent of U.S.-born county residents, according to the census averages, which span 2012 to 2016.
Pennsylvania Women Work got the idea for RISE after meeting immigrants and refugees at its 3 Cups of Coffee sessions, which connects women with mentors. Many of the foreign-born workers needed more than a mentor — they needed a way to translate experience in specialized fields like health care, law and finance.
“They find their previous experience and education are discounted by employers,” said Lisa Baranik, assistant professor of management at the University at Albany, State University of New York.
Ms. Baranik published a study in March that found that underemployment is one of the most significant stress factors reported by refugees — more frequently cited than the challenge of “meeting job requirements.”
“Nonprofit organizations need to give refugees more realistic expectations when they arrive,” she said. “Make it very clear from the beginning that is is going to be difficult to find a job, and there will be a lot of barriers to overcome.”
Pennsylvania Women Work handles one of the first barriers: It requests documents from the person’s foreign university and has the credentials verified by a service recognized by the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services.
That can take weeks and typically costs $400 to $500 — money that would be hard to scrape together while working an entry-level job.
In addition, the group gives a simple nudge to employers, Ms. Marsh-McClain said.
“When we have a client apply for a position, we contact the employer to say, ‘Can we get them a phone interview?’ ” she said.
In seven months, the initiative has improved prospects for some people, she said.
Among her clients, two former dentists have found another way into health care: One has started a dental hygienist program, and the other is pursuing a master’s degree in health administration.
There is also Thais Bentes Bahia, a 34-year-old former attorney who practiced family law in Brazil. She has been rejected from more than 80 positions since she immigrated here less than two years ago.
Big companies, she suspects, receive so many applications that “when they see you have all education in a foreign country, they put your resume aside and don’t pay much attention,” Ms. Bahia said. With the assistance of Pennsylvania Women Work, she recently got a job offer as a paralegal.
Others are waiting to get traction.
Mr. Khatiwoda, whose resume lists bachelor’s and master’s degrees, both in business studies from Tribhuvan University in Kathmandu, Nepal, said he knows he needs more time to get his certified public accountant certificate.
His wife, who traveled with him to the United States in 2014, just completed school and received her cosmetology license. She is working at a salon — her “dream job,” he said.
“Her part is done now,” he said. “In a few months, if I become a little bit established where I can get some knowledge, I will try to get accounting finance and banking jobs.”
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.