Victoria A. Lipnic grew up known as “the mayor’s daughter” in Carrolltown, a borough of roughly 1,000 people tucked into the Cambria County hills, about 80 miles east of Pittsburgh.
Today, as the top federal government official fighting workplace discrimination, she thinks often about her upbringing in small-town Western Pennsylvania, absorbing the example of her public-servant father, a schoolteacher and mayor for 25 years — “There’s no official in government more accountable to people than a mayor,” she said.
It was that spirit of answering to the public, Ms. Lipnic said, that propelled her into the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission during a time when the agency has quietly pushed the boundaries on what qualifies as discrimination, expanding protections for workers based on sexual orientation and gender identity.
A Republican nominated to the commission by President Barack Obama in 2010, Ms. Lipnic is also a rare example of even-keeled debate and compromise in Washington, D.C., where political gridlock has mired many federal agencies and boards.
During her eight-year tenure with the EEOC, she worked with Democratic colleagues to develop sexual harassment prevention guidelines years before the #MeToo movement erupted.
“The EEOC has a long history of operating in a bipartisan fashion,” Ms. Lipnic said in a recent interview. “I tell people all the time that we’re a very collegial group — and that continues today. The commissioners have a lot of real respect for each other and work very hard to find consensus on issues and agreement in areas of the law.”
Evolving civil rights interpretations
It was not until her late 20s that Ms. Lipnic waded into workplace discrimination law, which — while enshrined in civil rights statute — is subject to a constantly evolving set of interpretations.
Americans are protected from discrimination by employers based on set of characteristics — race, color, religion, disability, sex or national origin — first established by Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.
Ms. Lipnic, though she had angled toward international trade issues, left law school in the early 1990s to a torrent of employment reforms hitting the books: The Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 extended Title VII protections to employees with disabilities; a significant amendment to the Civil Rights Act arrived in 1991; and the Family Medical and Leave Act was approved in 1993.
“People were interested, and had to comply and learn these new laws,” she said.
“I was always really interested in jobs and economic development for people because I could see the difference that it would make in someone’s life. You could see it growing up in Western Pennsylvania and how important those opportunities are.”
Expanding protections through guidelines, lawsuits
Though Republicans were in a 3-2 minority when Ms. Lipnic joined the commission, she formed a close friendship with her Democratic chair at the time, Jacqueline Ann Berrien. Ms. Berrien encouraged her to convene a task force on sexual harassment.
“I was struck by the persistence and pervasiveness of the sexual harassment cases that we see at the EEOC every year,” she said. “We were wondering at the commission level, what more can we do on this topic?”
After years of research, the task force’s report published in June 2016 called for better training and prevention policies.
One of the biggest shifts came with a series of rulings and guidelines the commission issued beginning in 2012.
Though sexual orientation was not explicitly protected in 1964 civil rights law, the EEOC said it would interpret sex discrimination to include harassment against gay and transgender employees.
Since it revised its policy, the EEOC has collected roughly $6.4 million in fines for workers subject to LGBT discrimination, according to the agency’s website.
“The commission has been the leading government agency in extending anti-discrimination protections for the LGBT community,” said Charles Lamberton, a Pittsburgh employment discrimination lawyer.
“It’s been pushing and pushing and pushing that,” he said. “But for the commission’s aggressive position on that — and correct position on that — we would have not seen the court’s positions come down the way we’ve seen them coming down.”
In November, the commission won a case in Pittsburgh involving the harassment of a gay employee, with a federal judge ordering a South Hills health center to pay $55,000.
“It was just about validation, so people would believe me that this stuff happened,” said Dale Massaro, the plaintiff in the commission’s case.
Splitting with Trump
Ms. Lipnic said she has supported the EEOC’s efforts in advocating for protections based on sexual orientation and gender identity.
That puts her at odds with the Trump administration, which issued a memo last October reversing the civil rights of employees based on gender identity. The U.S. Justice Department and the EEOC also took opposite sides last year in an appeals court case involving sexual orientation workplace rights.
After becoming acting chair in January 2017, Ms. Lipnic said, “I decided early on, because we had from 2012 on taken in a lot of charges based on sexual orientation and that we were investigating them all around the country, that we should continue to pursue those.”
The Trump administration may not be too upset with the EEOC. In March, the president signed off on a $15.7 million increase in funding — the EEOC’s first budget hike in nine years.
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.