As the biggest threat to organized labor in recent memory advances this week before a conservative-leaning U.S. Supreme Court, labor unions have already begun to prepare for the fallout.

On Monday morning, hundreds of union members and supporters rallied in Mellon Square in Downtown and marched down Grant Street during morning rush hour to protest what they see as a corporate-funded attempt to bust unions nationwide. The crowd was mostly the Service Employees International Union, which represents public sector workers like 911 operators, unemployment compensation referees and human services staff.

“Today is a dark day,” said Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto. “It’s a day that is pushing us back 100 years.

Hundreds of labor advocates march in Pittsburgh​

“But let me tell you this: For anyone working in the City of Pittsburgh, I don’t care what they say. You are going to be represented, whether you’re the (Fraternal Order of Police), whether you’re the firefighters, whether you’re the SEIU, where you’re the laborers. We are going to recognize and we are going to respect it.”

Advertise with us

The case — Janus vs. the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees — centers on a clash between free speech and the right of public sector labor unions to collect fees from government workers who do not want representation.

AFSCME argues its fees are the modest and necessary cost to raise the standards of working people. The plaintiff, Mark Janus, an Illinois state government employee, argues that the union is forcing him to subsidize political views he doesn’t support, violating his First Amendment rights.

The case is the latest salvo in an escalating political debate over the dues-collecting power of unions.

Some states that have high rates of unionization and Republican-controlled legislatures have passed right-to-work laws that allow union employees, including those in the private sector, to opt out of paying dues. More than half of all states now have such laws, with Wisconsin, Michigan, Kentucky and West Virginia among the latest.

Pennsylvania does not have a right-to-work law.

Advertise with us

A ruling against organized labor in the Janus case would strike a more devastating blow, essentially making the right-to-work setup the nationwide law for public sector workers.

The public sector has been a bastion of support for labor unions as organized labor has declined in the private sector. About 34 percent of public sector workers — about 7.2 million people — were members of a union in 2017, compared with less than 7 percent of workers in the private sector, according to government data.

Labor advocates point out that government jobs, in particular, are a gateway to the middle class and stable careers for people such as teachers, bus drivers, and public safety workers like police, fireman and 911 operators.

The court is widely expected to back Mr. Janus along ideological lines.

Last year, the Supreme Court deadlocked 4-4 on a similar case in which a California teacher challenged a statewide labor union over mandatory fees. That ruling came following Justice Antonin Scalia's death and before the confirmation of Justice Neil Gorsuch, which restored the court’s 5-4 conservative majority.

Advertise with us

During oral arguments on Monday, Mr. Gorsuch reportedly stayed silent as his colleagues sparred with lawyers from both sides.

“You’re basically arguing, do away with unions,” Justice Sonia Sotomayor told William Messenger, a lawyer with the National Right to Work Legal Foundation, the group representing Mr. Janus.

On the other side, Justice Anthony Kennedy, who has voted against unions in past related cases, scoffed at labor’s argument that there is a difference between collective bargaining over government employees’ pay and benefits, and unions’ political activities, which nonmembers do not have to support.

If the unions lose, won’t they have less political influence, Mr. Kennedy asked David Frederick, representing the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees Illinois affiliate. Yes, Mr. Frederick said.

“Isn’t that the end of this case?” Mr. Kennedy replied.

Advertise with us

The case carries high stakes. There are about 735,000 U.S. public sector workers are represented by unions but are not members, or about 9 percent of all those represented. Those people would be seen as likely to stop paying their dues should the court rule against the union.

Unions are legally required in most cases to represent all employees in an organized workplace — regardless of whether the employees are members.

“Our view is it’s fair to pay a fee for a service you receive,” said Wythe Keever, spokesman for the Pennsylvania State Education Association, in an interview last week. “Fee-payers benefit from collective bargaining agreements in terms of wages, benefits and working conditions.”

Mr. Keever said the statewide union of public school employees has about 7,000 nonmember fee-payers and 181,000 dues-paying members — about 1 non-member for every 25 members.

“We’ve been providing services as a labor union for a long time and we have a strong record,” said Mr. Keever. “We’re going to continue to reach out to non-members.”

Advertise with us

Sam Williamson, a regional leader for the Service Employees International Union, said there’s a concern that current members could be convinced to drop out of the union following a ruling in favor of Janus.

“What we have to do is be pro-active about that,” Mr. Williamson said. “To go and talk to members and make sure we’re running an aggressive campaign to get people to not only stay in their union, but to go organize thousands of more workers to grow the union.”

The outcome of such campaigns could vary from union to union.

“The big question is whether public unions can extract political money from a smaller membership and remain as powerful,” said Daniel DiSalvo, senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute and an associate professor of political science at the City College of New York-CUNY. “Obviously, the public sector unions, in states where they’re strong, are political powerhouses.”

Mr. DiSalvo, who has opted out of his union in New York, said he pays the labor organization more than $1,000 each year. Though he acknowledges collective bargaining can produce better wages, he argued that, generally speaking, some workers oppose unions for other reasons.

Advertise with us

“You might think the grievance procedure only protects low-performers, and that all these job protection measures, while they’re nice, they only protect bad teachers,” he said.

Unions have made it so that “everyone should be forced to be a union member, that would just make it simple. That obviously violated your First Amendment.”

Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore. The Associated Press contributed.