About 1.1 million manufacturing jobs have been created since manufacturing employment hit bottom in early 2010.

That must be good news, right?

But it’s not the whole story.

Alan Tonelson, a former U.S. Business and Industry Council analyst who writes the RealityChek blog on economic, trade and related issues, has made a habit of examining how much manufacturing jobs actually pay. The truth is uncomfortable.

Advertise with us

Based on inflation-adjusted figures from the U.S. Department of Labor, real manufacturing wages have risen 0.8 percent since March 2010, Mr. Tonelson reports. That means for every $100 that manufacturing workers were earning back then, they are making $100.80 today.

Workers in the automotive sector, which has accounted for about 1 in 4 manufacturing jobs created since then, haven’t been as fortunate. Mr. Tonelson said their inflation-adjusted pay has fallen 3.9 percent over that period. That means workers in that sector are making $96.10 for every $100 they made eight years ago.

He said the story is the same for other types of production workers. Those in computers and related electronics industries have seen real wages fall 2.5 percent. Inflation-adjusted wages for metal fabricators and workers who make plastic and rubber products have fallen about 0.2 percent.

Aerospace workers have seen real wage gains of 4.9 percent over the same period. But Mr. Tonelson said jobs in that sector have risen less than 1 percent during that time. Real wages for machinery workers have risen 7.7 percent, he said.

It is hard to reconcile lagging wages with manufacturers’ constant complaint that they can’t find workers, a shortage that should lead to higher wages.

Advertise with us

“They’re simply not behaving the way economic textbooks say they should be behaving,” Mr. Tonelson said.

He said the post-recession period continues a disturbing trend in manufacturing wages, which peaked on an inflation-adjusted basis in the late 1970s.

Manufacturing pay is a little bit better when compensation is measured when salaries and benefits for industry workers are added to the wage figures, Mr. Tonelson said. But that doesn’t change the underlying story of poor manufacturing compensation performance, he said.

One of the main reasons for the decline has been the decision by manufacturers to move production outside the U.S. Mr. Tonelson said the automotive industry is a prime example.

“The option of offshoring production is simply too easy for companies. Manufacturing workers know this and therefore they have been much more accepting of lower wages,” he said.

Advertise with us

Why has so little attention been paid to this trend?

“Policymakers and journalists don’t look closely at economic data,” Mr. Tonelson said. “The jobs figures, especially when you’re talking about manufacturing, have tended to overshadow everything else.”

He said another sign of weakness in manufacturing is inflation-adjusted production figures. Taking out the effect of inflation, the value of what American manufacturers produce today is 2.3 percent lower than it was when production peaked at the end of 2007.

“We haven’t had a stretch of manufacturing that poor since the Great Depression,” Mr. Tonelson said.

Meanwhile, demand for those goods hasn’t decreased. But it is being satisfied by imports, not American workers, he said.

Advertise with us

“It’s not only shoes and toys and clothing. It’s advanced manufacturing products,” he said.

Mr. Tonelson believes U.S. trade policy must be adjusted if American workers are to collect bigger paychecks. He credited President Donald Trump with jawboning companies to either return production to the U.S. or open new plants here.

“This is a president who seems, unlike his predecessors, to understand the so-called bully pulpit still means a lot when you’re talking about manufacturing,” he said.

Despite the rash of announcements of companies giving workers raises and bonuses in the wake of the tax cuts enacted last month. Mr. Tonelson is skeptical that lower tax rates will improve the inflation-adjusted wages of manufacturing workers.

Their pay could get a boost if Mr. Trump follows through on his promises to invest in the nation’s infrastructure, especially if the program includes stronger “buy American” requirements than have been imposed in the past, he said.

Business@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1601.