Lawmakers gathered in Washington, D.C., on Tuesday to press for fresh legislation to shore up pensions for about 117,000 union coal miners at risk of losing their retirement savings amid a coal industry decline.
Yet significant political hurdles remain, even after Congress managed to extend health care benefits for 22,000 retired miners in May just as those benefits were set to expire.
The American Miners Pension Act has the same goal as the Miners Protection Act, which was heavily pushed by coal state senators and ultimately stuffed into a short-term spending bill last December that funded the government for four months.
In the U.S. Capitol Building on Tuesday, the same coalition of lawmakers — led by West Virginia Sens. Joe Manchin, a Democrat, and Shelley Moore Capito, a Republican — explained that the new bill would redirect surplus funds from an abandoned mine reclamation program into a United Mine Workers of America pension fund teetering on the brink of insolvency.
Pennsylvania Sen. Bob Casey, who was one of the most vocal advocates for the Miners Protection Act, was not present at the press conference but is supportive of the new bill, a spokeswoman said.
“Our miners have upheld their promise to their employers, to their families and in many cases to their country,” Mr. Casey said in a statement. “Congress must keep its promise to our coal miners. I won’t stop fighting for this commonsense, bipartisan proposal until we do.”
Read More
Lawmakers added a provision that directs the Treasury Department to loan the miners’ pension fund up to $600 million annually for at least four years, an amount that the fund would eventually pay back over a 30-year term.
“Every day we wait, it gets more expensive,” Mr. Manchin said.
The UMWA pension funds are currently going to more than 87,000 miners nationwide, including 13,000 miners in Pennsylvania. The average check is $586 a month, Mr. Manchin said. Another 20,000 miners are vested for their pensions but have not yet begun drawing them.
The pension funds took a beating during the Great Recession and never recovered. In addition, a sharp downturn in the coal industry pushed more than 50 companies, including four of the largest coal giants, into bankruptcy proceedings.
“We have less money coming in with the amount of people working” and paying into the fund, Mr. Manchin added. “I just don’t know how you can turn your back on the people who built America.”
The loan would “allow the UMWA 1974 Pension Fund to escape trouble faster and limit the longer-term need for government assistance,” United Mine Workers spokesman Phil Smith said in an email, adding that it could make the proposal more palatable for more lawmakers on Capitol Hill.
It was unclear just how much money would flow into pension funds under the bill, which has not yet been analyzed by budget officials.
A budget score last November for the Miners Protection Act showed the UMWA’s pension fund needed $1.4 billion over the next 10 years. With a loan from the Treasury Department, the amount drawn from abandoned mine lands funds is expected to be less than that, Mr. Smith said.
The Abandoned Mine Lands program, managed by the U.S. Department of the Interior, is a pot of money collected from coal companies to fund mine restoration projects. Since its creation in 1977, the program has collected over $10 billion through a fee assessed on each ton of coal produced.
If the struggle to pass the Miners Protection Act is any example, obstacles still stand in the way of the new bill.
For one, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell refused to bring the full Miners Protection Act up for a standalone vote, despite threats from Mr. Manchin and Mr. Casey to shut down the government in December over the issue.
Instead, Mr. McConnell split the pension and health care initiatives, and allowed permanent health care benefits to be attached to a broader spending package Congress approved at the end of April. The pension issue remained unaddressed.
Another split comes between eastern and western coal states. Wyoming lawmakers have balked at the idea of using excess abandoned mine land funds for miner pensions, a dispute on which the West Virginia lawmakers said they have not made much progress.
“The short answer is, no, Wyoming is not on board,” Ms. Moore Capito said, adding that the lawmakers will “see where we can reach compromise.”
Mr. Manchin said he’s confident President Donald J. Trump will join the push for the bill. “He’s been very vocal about his support for this from day one,” Mr. Manchin said.
Union officials have said pensions honor a promise by the federal government dating to the Truman administration to guarantee UMWA retirement funds.
In 1947, settling a nationwide dispute between mine owners and the union, then-President Harry S. Truman signed an executive order that created a national pension and health care agreement. Those actions were precedent for the Coal Act in 1992, which ensured lifetime healthcare following a nasty strike when companies were trying to avoid paying health care.
The wave of bankruptcies today carry similar consequences for workers as the difficult times in 1940s and late-1980s, union officials argue.
“Congress took the first step toward fulfilling America’s promise to retired coal miners and their families by passing legislation to preserve their health care earlier this year,” said Cecil Roberts, international president of the UMWA.
“With the passage of this legislation, Congress will take the final step and ensure that the people who put their lives and their health on the line to provide the fuel that made America the strongest country on earth get the retirement security they earned through a lifetime of dangerous, backbreaking work,” Mr. Roberts said.
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.