Since at least 2008, more than 13,000 people have sought to work at CSX Transportation’s freight rail yard in Huntington, W.Va., hoping for a career as a conductor, electrician, track worker, painter or material handler/clerk.
All of those people — either applicants or current employees working across 38 job titles — were required by the Jacksonville, Fla.-based rail company to strap into what is called an isokinetic machine that measures muscle strength.
Many candidates might not have had an issue with the test — work for a rail line can often involve physically demanding labor. But the test results tell a different story, as reported by federal regulators who have been investigating CSX for months.
In August, the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission filed a class-action lawsuit claiming that the outcomes of the test show it discriminates against women.
According to the EEOC’s suit, filed in U.S. District Court for the Southern District of West Virginia, while nearly 9 in 10 men passed with the top strength score, just 3 in 10 women could say the same.
Even at a lower passing score, more than half of women failed compared with men’s failure rate of 6 percent.
The suit also targets two other tests that the EEOC argues women fail significantly more often than men: a “step test” to measure aerobic capacity and an “ergometer test” to measure arm strength.
Those results, if accurate, show a clear disparity in how the tests affect a certain class of people — as determined by sex, race, age, religion, sexual orientation and other characteristics — that the agency is tasked with protecting from workplace discrimination. The agency was formed as part of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.
CSX, in a written statement to the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, said that it is “committed to its obligations under the law, including federal anti-discrimination laws, and the company will defend its rigorous attention to inclusiveness and safety.”
The case is one of the few nationally that probe adverse impacts of tests used as a condition of employment, labor experts said. Employers in all industries are known to use assessments, often put together by third parties, meant to select certain physical and cognitive abilities and personality traits.
But such tests can have myriad unintended consequences and must be statistically validated to show they predict job safety and performance.
“Any time an employer wants to look at testing, they need to be very deliberate about how they go about doing it,” said Mark Phillis, a employment lawyer in Littler Mendelson’s Downtown office. “There are many traps for them.”
If properly designed, employment tests can give hiring managers information that a resume or interview may not reveal, said Jeffery Bondy, an industrial organizational psychologist for Predictive Synergistic Systems. The Cranberry-based firm produces, with Mr. Bondy’s oversight, a personality test that employers in industries like energy, health care and food service can use to ensure they have the right candidate.
The online test, which takes about six minutes, gives people a list of 86 descriptors such as social, relaxed, relentless, responsive, realistic and formal. It asks people to describe the way others expect them to act, then asks them to describe how they actually act.
“We are looking at personality traits that are predictive of behavior that are associated with success on the role,” Mr. Bondy said.
Compared with tests that measure cognitive or physical abilities, the EEOC tends to be “far more accepting of a personality assessment,” he added. Personality tests assess the degree to which a person has certain traits or dispositions that fit into a specific job, and “no particular sub-group enjoys an advantage over the other sub-groups when it involves certain behavioral traits or levels of integrity,” Mr. Bondy said.
Meanwhile, the company that manufactured the isokinetic machine used by CSX defended the effectiveness of its product but declined to comment on the EEOC lawsuit. A statement from a spokeswoman for Biodex, based in Shirley, N.Y., said employers use the product to prevent workplace injuries by selectively testing muscles.
The case could represent an uphill battle for the government as it waits for CSX’s response in court.
Mr. Phillis at Littler Mendelson said plenty of jobs, especially in industries like public safety and manufacturing, have successfully defended tests that result in better passing rates for men.
Still, he said, even if the railroad operator can demonstrate that people passing the test work safer and more effectively than those who don’t, it must take into account the differing results for men and women. In such cases, the law requires an employer to explore alternate tests.
The key is establishing whether — and how — CSX validated the test to be used for each of the 38 specific job titles that it is used for in choosing candidates.
“Often in these cases, there’s a battle of statistical experts,” Mr. Phillis said.
Though unusual, accusations of physical tests leading to sex discrimination are not unprecedented. In July 2014, the Justice Department sued the Pennsylvania State Police over physical fitness tests that disproportionately screened out female applicants applying for trooper positions.
The state argued its tests had been validated by experts and are specifically related to the state police trooper job. A federal judge stayed that case in December 2016 to consider several motions, according to court records.
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.