Ray Yeager swelled with pride as he strolled through his company’s 250,000-square-foot manufacturing plant in Monongahela.

Machines rhythmically pounded sheet metal into complex shapes and various sizes; conveyors dropped finished pieces into cardboard boxes; automatic mechanical arms placed boxes onto wooden pallets. A legion of workers drove forklifts to take the pallets out for shipment.

Parts made here are used in heating, ventilation and air conditioning systems in the United States, Canada and Mexico.

It’s the type of operation that remains a distant memory for other workers in the Pittsburgh region. Kenneth Love worked for 22 years at a General Motors metal stamping plant in West Mifflin, which shuttered in 2008 after more than five decades.

Advertise with us

“They promised us a future for our grandchildren to work there,” said Mr. Love, who retired just before the closure and became a minister and labor union activist. “It didn’t last 10 years.”

The two clashing narratives largely hinge on one plot twist that has had profound effects for American business and labor: the North American Free Trade Agreement.

It’s a fierce debate that has been revived and electrified by President Donald Trump’s decision this year to renegotiate the 1994 trade pact, which opened up the U.S. to free trade with Canada and Mexico.

As the three countries attempt to hammer out a new deal in secret, businesses and labor groups in Pittsburgh are on the edge of their seats. The unpredictability of what the Trump administration will propose — ranging from leaving controversial provisions intact to assessing tariffs on imports to pulling out of the trade pact altogether — seems to have all sides prepared for the worst in vastly different ways.

While labor groups generally want the agreement scaled back or gone, manufacturers fear losing established business partners.

Advertise with us

NAFTA opened up roughly $3 million in annual sales for Mr. Yeager’s DMI Companies, a Charleroi-based manufacturer of products used in HVAC systems for commercial buildings like hospitals, schools and apartment complexes. Employing about 450 workers, the company exports directly to Canada and sells to a supplier in Texas that ships DMI materials for use in Mexico’s buildings.

“I’m a big believer in free trade,” Mr. Yeager said. He worries that if the U.S. were to put strict tariffs on imports of, say, Canadian softwood lumber, Canada could impose retaliatory tariffs on his products.

“Then it becomes more of a political issue than an economic debate,” he said. “If there are no tariffs or quotas, then it’s supply and demand, and the most efficient manufacturers are going to survive.”

The U.S. currently has 14 free trade agreements in effect with 20 countries, deals that sustain the Pittsburgh region more than many other cities its size.

Pittsburgh-area companies export an average of $10.5 billion worth of goods and services to other countries, ranking the region 25th in the nation among metro areas, according to the U.S. Department of Commerce data from 2005 to 2015.

Advertise with us

Of those, NAFTA represents $3.5 billion in exports each year to Canada and Mexico, according to the data. 

Pittsburgh companies find customers abroad Each year, trade with other countries has provided billions of dollars in sales for hundreds of businesses in the Pittsburgh region.

Created with Highstock 5.0.14U.S. dollarsTotal exportsNAFTA exports2006200820102012201402.5G5G7.5G10G12.5G15G17.5G

Total Pittsburgh exports, 2005-15 Sales to Canada and Mexico under the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) account for about 30 percent of all sales.

Created with Highstock 5.0.14Other exportsOther exportsNAFTA exports 30.7%NAFTA exports 30.7%

Advertise with us

Source: U.S. Department of Commerce | graphic: James Hilston/Post-Gazette

While economists generally conclude large corporations and businesses have reaped enormous benefits from expanded markets, labor groups have railed against trade deals — seeing them as a way to exploit cheap labor in other countries. Mr. Trump was propelled to the White House last year, in part, by promising to tear up trade deals and erect economic barriers.

Mr. Trump pulled out of the Trans-Pacific Partnership with 12 other countries and has reportedly considered pulling out of a five-year-old trade deal with South Korea. In August, he tweeted that NAFTA was the “worst trade deal ever made” and floated terminating it.

Still, few details have leaked from the trade talks between the three countries. The goal is to announce a deal by the end of the year.

Labor advocates are pressing for a number of measures that they say will bring stricter enforcement of labor standards. This includes removing a provision that allows investors to sue foreign governments over rules or regulations they don’t like, bypassing a country’s court system. Labor advocates also want better verification that products are made with American parts.

Advertise with us

Those actions were discussed last month during a town hall in West Mifflin hosted by U.S. Rep. Mike Doyle, D-Forest Hills. In a phone interview last week, Mr. Doyle said many of his constituents ended up on the losing side of NAFTA.

“If the trade-off is we get cheaper tennis shoes but communities are devastated … those are not the trade deals we’re interested in,” Mr. Doyle said.

Mr. Love said he remembers hearing whispers of a North American trade deal in the late 1980s while he was president of UAW Local 544, which represented hundreds of workers at GM's Pittsburgh Metal Stamping Division.

GM presented NAFTA to its employees, he said, as a way to lift up all workers by making the American facilities part of a larger team, he said. When the pact finally took effect, the operation “unraveled immediately,” he said, with the workforce shrinking through attrition and the company moving stamping operations elsewhere.

Last week, a spokesperson for General Motors declined to comment on why the company had closed the facility.

Advertise with us

Knowing the plant was set to close, Mr. Love began taking night classes at Geneva College in Beaver County to become a minister and a union advocate.

NAFTA “is a battle I’ve been fighting my whole life,” said Mr. Love, who sits on the Pennsylvania Fair Trade Coalition, a statewide group that advocates for worker-friendly policies in trade deals.

Acknowledging global trade is here to stay, he said he favors a provision in the trade agreement that requires collective bargaining at foreign plants — a way to improve lives of low-wage foreign workers and keep more jobs in America.

“We’re just looking for a fair deal, that’s all,” he said.

Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore.