State Labor Secretary Kathy Manderino gave an impassioned defense of her agency’s handling of Pennsylvania’s unemployment compensation services before lawmakers Tuesday — and she called the program “broken” following a funding lapse last fall that triggered layoffs of 500 people and the closure of three call centers.
Ms. Manderino appeared before the Senate Appropriations Committee in Harrisburg to discuss Gov. Tom Wolf’s budget request of $71 million to fund the Department of Labor and Industry for the next fiscal year, beginning July 1.
But with thousands of out-of-work residents enduring long wait times and busy signals to get unemployment pay, the elephant in the room was another big pot of money outside of the budget request: nearly $58 million that Senate lawmakers declined to renew this calendar year.
“It’s a wounded system. It’s a broken system,” Ms. Manderino said. “The customers and employers of Pennsylvania are not getting the kind of service they deserve.”
The hearing was Ms. Manderino’s first public appearance before some of the lawmakers who adjourned in November without passing a bill to reauthorize funding to keep call centers, appeals offices and other unemployment functions open and fully staffed.
The Service Infrastructure and Improvement Fund was created by the state Legislature in 2013 to redirect money from the unemployment compensation trust fund to be used to improve administration of the program. (Funded by a federal payroll tax on employees and employers, the trust fund offers paychecks for up to 26 weeks to people who lose their job through no fault of their own.)
At that time and in the weeks since, Senate Republicans expressed frustration that the Wolf administration had not given satisfactory responses to how that administrative money was used and the progress made. They also have said the agency should have planned for the possibility that the funding — about $178 million over the last four years — would not be renewed.
In December, Ms. Manderino closed call centers in Altoona, Allentown and Lancaster, and laid off staff across all offices in the unemployment program.
Ms. Manderino is scheduled to appear for two hours Wednesday morning before the House Labor and Industry Committee to discuss the layoffs and service delays, which would be the first public hearing on the issue. In a visit last month to the Pittsburgh area’s call center, she said there did not appear to be a compromise in sight.
The rift was on full display in a heated exchange with Sen. Scott Wagner, a York Republican who in January launched his bid to challenge Gov. Tom Wolf’s 2018 re-election. Mr. Wagner has been critical of the agency’s handling of the closures and suggested Ms. Manderino purposely shut down high-performing centers to make a political statement — an allegation he repeated Tuesday.

Scott Wagner, a York Republican, engaged in heated discussions Tuesday with Labor Secretary Kathy Manderino. (Pam Panchak/Post-Gazette)
“Isn’t it disingenuous to blame our lack of action on H.B. 2375 for the closure of these centers?” Mr. Wagner asked. “It seems to me that this was a political opportunity.”
“This was a fiscal decision that I hated to make and had no choice,” Ms. Manderino responded, adding that she included rent costs and local unemployment rates in determining where to cut. “There were no good choices.”
Mr. Wagner continued: Gov. Wolf had told laid-off call center workers that “elections have consequences” and urged them to call Republican offices. “What did he mean by that?”
Ms. Manderino responded, “What I thought was that when people who don’t believe in government run for public office, people who don’t value the service that public workers provide to their constituents ... that this is what happens.”
Other Republicans cited Auditor General Eugene DePasquale’s review of the unemployment program, which will likely be finished in April.
“I think the audit is very, very crucial to this,” said Sen. Lisa Baker, R-Luzerne, who had called for an audit of the program. “You can well imagine how many members had a belief this wasn’t done properly, and we have a difference of opinion what the intentions were.”
Meanwhile, wait times on hold doubled in January “from under an hour to more than two hours,” Ms. Manderino told the committee.
“When folks ask me what is the exit strategy, you are seeing what the system looks like not using SIIF dollars,” she said.
While the unemployment issue took center stage, Ms. Manderino also discussed her support for the governor’s proposed minimum wage hike to $12 an hour, up from $7.25 an hour.
Annual statistics compiled by Labor and Industry, also released Tuesday, showed 145,400 workers in Pennsylvania earned the minimum wage or less — about 4 percent of all hourly workers. Pennsylvania last raised its minimum wage in 2009, from $7.15 to $7.25.
Ms. Manderino also said her agency is focused on expanding training opportunities in coal country and supporting programs that can employ people in industries around Shell Chemical’s ethane cracker plant in Beaver County.
One issue of bipartisan agreement was in support of the services provided by Steel Valley Authority, a nonprofit based in Swissvale that works to help manufacturers avoid layoffs. With current state funding at about $1.5 million, it has worked with more than 1,200 manufacturing firms throughout its 30-year history and has helped save over 21,500 jobs, according to its executive director, Thomas Croft.
While the department provides funding for high-level programs, Ms. Manderino said, “The rubber hits the road at the local level. The more we can do to encourage our local businesses to be actively involved with their local workforce boards, the better. They’re the ones who know what they need and what their employment outlook looks like.”
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.