In the summer of 2013, Pennsylvania labor officials came to grips with reality: A massive software overhaul of the state’s unemployment compensation system was broken beyond repair.

The modernization project, initiated in 2006 with a budget of $107 million, was 3½ years behind schedule and faced a $60 million cost overrun, according to a report released that summer by Carnegie Mellon University’s Software Engineering Institute.

After dropping contractor IBM from the job, the Pennsylvania Department of Labor and Industry charted a new path — with a new pot of money. As federal funding declined, state lawmakers authorized the agency to dip into the unemployment compensation trust fund to improve administration of the program and to find another vendor.

Now, a fiery political dispute over progress the agency has made with that funding — about $178 million over the last four years — has plagued the unemployment system again.

Advertise with us

Effective Dec. 19, more than 500 workers will be laid off and three of the state’s eight call centers will close. Thousands of out-of-work Pennsylvanians and their legal advocates are bracing for the return of long wait times during the busiest time of year — systemic problems they thought were things of the past.

Political fighting

The dramatic cuts came after Senate Republicans left Harrisburg last month without renewing the funding for another year, leaving the agency without $58 million that, state officials said, lawmakers led them to believe would be approved for 2017.

Since then, Gov. Tom Wolf and Senate Republicans each have blamed the other for using workers as political pawns.

Mr. Wolf provided a trove of documents showing at least 12 times labor and industry officials had met with or shared information with Senate Republicans this year about the reauthorization, including how the money was spent and how the claims process improved. Documents noted the money would amount to about 27 percent of total program funding in 2017.

Advertise with us

“All told, countless meetings were held with members and staff of your caucus, and significant documentation justifying reauthorization as well as the ramifications of (failing to reauthorize) was provided,” Mr. Wolf wrote.

In response, Republicans insisted the governor is unnecessarily shutting down the three centers, in Altoona, Allentown and Lancaster, to punish them.

Last week, state Sen. Scott Wagner, R-York, held a press conference announcing he had requested copies of email discussions from labor and industry employees about the closing of the centers. Mr. Wagner said the governor is conspiring against Republicans after visiting the soon-to-be-shuttered call center in Lancaster and speaking with workers.

“There's been a great deal of speculation about the timing and the need for these layoffs,” Mr. Wagner said, claiming that Mr. Wolf is “a failed governor that is seeking to salvage his political career, and he's using the livelihood of state employees as pawns to do so.”

Separately, Sen. Lisa Baker, R-Luzerne and chair of the labor and industry committee, wrote to Auditor General Eugene DePasquale to request an evaluation of the funds and whether they were used properly.

Advertise with us

Origin of funding

Funded by a federal payroll tax on employees and employers, Pennsylvania’s unemployment trust fund offers paychecks for up to 26 weeks to people who lose their job through no fault of their own.

People who file claims have to show they are eligible, and both employers and former employees can challenge a claim’s decision.

The agency has said for years that decisions and appeals are slowed by an inefficient and costly computer system installed more than 40 years ago.

In 2006, the agency selected IBM, the New York-based technology corporation, to upgrade the software. It was not until years into the project that labor officials noticed critical errors within IBM’s work, according to the CMU report in 2013. While IBM engineers were at fault, the report found “red flags and warnings were not acted upon decisively” by the department.

Advertise with us

When the economy improved and claims returned to normal levels, federal funding receded. But lawmakers devised a way for the department to continue improving its systems: Act 34 of 2013 diverted some money each year from the trust fund and into a newly created Service and Infrastructure Improvement Fund, scheduled to lapse at the end of 2016.

Requests for information

In April, agency officials began lobbying for lawmakers to pass a one-year extension of the funding, highlighting improvements that had been made.

In a document dated May 24, Kevin Cicak, deputy secretary for unemployment compensation programs, noted the percentage of first payments on an initial claim made within 14 days filed hit 93 percent in the first quarter of this year, up from 81 percent in the first quarter of 2012. Appeals approved within 30 days or less improved to 85 percent from 39 percent.

That document also provided pie charts showing how the money had been spent in broad categories each of the four years.

Advertise with us

In another letter, dated Aug. 22, the agency explained it had “virtualized” the phone system so that a call to a service center can go anywhere in the state to the next available agent. The agency paid for interpreter services for deaf claimants and enhancements to the online tax system that serves 300,000 employers.

Money was used to find a software vendor to replace IBM. The agency is reviewing bids to select a new vendor by Jan. 18, said department spokeswoman Sara Goulet, and the funding lapse could affect how that project moves forward, if at all.

Republicans indicated they wanted more from the agency.

After Mr. Wolf released his trove of documents, Jennifer Kocher, spokeswoman for the Senate Republicans, said that information had not been good enough.

“We maintain — as we have for many months — that the administration's public accounting should include specific projects, expenditures and timelines, as well as a detailed plan outlining future transfers, and a timeframe for elimination of extraordinary funding,” she wrote.

Advertise with us

“Unfortunately, to date, we have yet to receive that and this letter rehashing the history of their communications with us does nothing to move that forward.”

Ms. Baker asked Mr. DePasquale to parse the agency’s management of the centers and whether the extension is necessary.

In a statement, Mr. DePasquale said he had received “several” requests for audits of the centers and he was “taking all of them seriously.” He said he would decide whether to take up a review by early January.

Problems resurfacing

With the two sides at an impasse and lawmakers off until January, advocates for the unemployed say the benefits program is entering a crisis that harms the most vulnerable people at the worst time of year.

Advertise with us

“It's getting back to the problems experienced a few years ago,” said Ed Ehrhart, chief legal officer for the Mon Valley Unemployed Committee, a nonprofit based on the North Side.

“I have received numerous calls from individuals over the past three business days who can't even get in line to speak to anyone, having tried repeatedly during the entire business day to do so,” he said.

Calls to the service center last week returned busy signals on Tuesday, wait times of about one hour on Wednesday afternoon, and busy signals again on Thursday morning.

People can file claims online at www.uc.pa.gov, or in person at any CareerLink office.

No matter how they are filed, claims go to service center staff for eligibility determinations. Claimants must also call to follow up on the status of their claim.

Advertise with us

In recent years, initial unemployment claims roughly doubled from November to January, hitting a high of more than 33,000 a week in January, according to department data. Plus, lawmakers passed a bill last month that opens up eligibility to 44,000 more seasonal workers.

The call center layoffs affect about 42 percent of workers across the entire unemployment program, which employed about 1,247 people as of this fall. The Pittsburgh region’s claims call center in Duquesne remains open.

Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore. Karen Langley contributed reporting.