Pennsylvania tax reviewers have been giving extra scrutiny to claimed unreimbursed employee expenses on state income tax filings as part of an initiative to root out intentional or accidental misreporting in recent years.
Taxpayers taking deductions for expenses that their jobs require but that their employers don’t pay for — like union dues, travel costs, equipment purchases, continuing education or uniforms — are now more likely to get a letter from the state seeking documentation to prove the deductions are necessary.
So what can a taxpayer claiming legitimate expenses do to avoid getting an unwelcome letter from the revenue department this spring?
A good first stop is the agency’s website. The department published clearer guidance about allowable expenses and supporting documentation after it faced criticism about the initiative’s sweep and implementation in 2014, its first year. It also shifted away from denying claims without first seeking documents to back them up.
Early this year, the department gave notice that taxpayers claiming unreimbursed business expenses should provide a verification letter from employers, or submit a copy of the employer’s reimbursement policy or a signed affidavit.
Taxpayers can, but are not required to, provide the supporting documents when they file their returns, Department of Revenue spokesman Kevin Hensil said. “If there is a considerable amount of documentation, we recommend taxpayers wait until we contact them,” he said.
The value of taxpayers’ deductions, and their tolerance for potential scrutiny and delays, can help determine whether it is worth it for them to go through the effort of getting letters from their employers or other documentation before filing their taxes.
“If they are going to save more than a couple hundred dollars of tax, they are going to want to pursue it and they’ll put the time into it,” said Daria Palaschak, a tax partner with downtown CPA firm Sisterson & Co. LLP.
On the other hand, she said, “You have to think about what the tax practitioner is going to have to incur in time to direct the client to go get all this stuff and make sure it’s sufficient. There is a cutoff where it is just not prudent for them to pay the tax practitioner more than the savings they are going to get.”
In that case, clients tend to either list the unreimbursed expenses and see if they get challenged or just drop the claims, she said.
The Department of Revenue’s website lists ways to document different kinds of unreimbursed expenses. Union dues, for example, can be verified with the year’s final pay stub or a receipt, while more complicated expenses for things like meals and entertainment should be documented with receipts, information on the business purpose of the expense, and employer verification that the expense was required.
A good rule of thumb is that the larger and more unusual the expense — Jeffrey Spengler, a partner at accounting firm Baker Tilly Virchow Krause’s Downtown office, used a physician’s purchase of a piece of laboratory equipment as an example — the more detailed records a taxpayer should include.
Mr. Hensil said fewer letters have been sent and fewer refunds have been adjusted each year since the department’s initiative began, a trend that indicates that the agency has improved its process and taxpayers have adjusted to the increased scrutiny.
For the 2014 tax year, the agency sent 33,308 letters requesting documentation and adjusted 33,078 refunds, saving the commonwealth $6.6 million, he said. For the 2015 tax year, through September 2016, the department sent 23,792 letters and adjusted 19,098 refunds, for a savings of $3.6 million.
Accountants still dislike the Department of Revenue’s initiative, saying it discourages people from claiming appropriate deductions and takes advantage of people’s disinclination to bother fighting for deductions if they aren’t that big.
“They throw a net out there that captures a lot of taxpayers that certainly have legitimate expenses,” Mr. Spengler said.
“In our practice, we’ll certainly want to deduct any valid expense that you have, and you should certainly not be afraid to do so,” he said. “But you may have people who just don’t want to go through that scrutiny.”
Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.