A club that treats its exotic dancers as tenants by making them lease the stage for performances can't force a stripper's wage lawsuit into arbitration through the terms of a landlord/tenant agreement.
Judge Julio Fuentes of the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled recently that the Gold Club can't circumvent Fair Labor Standards Act claims by legally treating its dancers as tenants rather than employees, stressing that wage claims fall squarely within the realm of employment law regardless of any lease agreement. Judge Fuentes' decision affirms a ruling from the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania.
Former Gold Club dancer Jessica Herzfeld filed a wage-and-hour class action on behalf of herself and other strippers in 2014, claiming the club violated minimum wage laws.
The Gold Club argued that since the dancers were tenants, the claims had to be resolved through arbitration, as mentioned in the landlord/tenant agreements each dancer had to sign.
Judge Fuentes disagreed and said the club's clever attempts to use a lease to avoid labor laws also had an unanticipated consequence.
“In an effort to limit its liabilities under labor-employment laws by designating its contracts with the exotic dancers as landlord/tenant leases, the Gold Club has likewise limited the scope of its arbitration clauses,” Judge Fuentes said. “The FLSA and its state counterparts cannot be so easily circumvented. The rights embodied in the FLSA — 'minimum wages and maximum work hours' — are absolute and unwaivable.”
He added, “The arbitration clause contained therein expressly states that it applies only to 'dispute[s] aris[ing] out of this agreement.' Herzfeld's wage-and-hour claims, however, do not arise out of the lease agreement. In fact, the agreement deliberately states that it 'negate[s] any employment relationship.' Of course, an individual does not forfeit her rights as an employee under the FLSA simply by signing a cleverly drawn up contract.”
Through the landlord/tenant agreement, Ms. Herzfeld and others had to pay Gold Club a certain amount of money per shift to use the stage. Dancers were not allowed to perform without signing the contract.
Ms. Herzfeld claimed she was given the agreement and told to sign it in the middle of one of her night shifts. She claimed she had already had two glasses of wine at the time, and was told that she couldn't bring the contract home for review. Judge Fuentes described the agreement containing the arbitration clause as “error and typo-ridden.”
Matthew Hoffer of Shafer & Associates in Lansing, Mich., represented the Gold Club and declined to comment. Ms. Herzfeld's lawyer, Edwin J. Kilpela of Carlson Lynch Sweet Kilpela & Carpenter in Pittsburgh, did not return a call seeking comment.
P.J. D'Annunzio: 215-557-2315 or pdannunzio@alm.com. On Twitter @PJDannunzioTLI. For more articles like this: www.thelegalintelligencer.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.