Pittsburgh continues to underperform other major metro areas when it comes to launching new businesses, according to an annual study by the Kansas City, Mo.-based Ewing Marion Kauffman Foundation.
For the second straight year, the Pittsburgh region came in dead last among 40 large cities ranked by startup creation.
Tech center Austin, Texas, topped the Startup Activity Index released today by the foundation. Austin also topped the list in 2015.
The foundation — which provides grants, research and educational programs to foster entrepreneurship — used federal census and labor statistics to track startup activity based on the percent of adults who start new businesses each month, how many of them hire employees within the first year, and how many launch their companies based on a market opportunity rather than out of necessity.
Compared with the 2015 index, Pittsburgh experienced an increase in the percent of new entrepreneurs who started their companies for opportunity vs. necessity.
Of new entrepreneurs in the region, 65 percent launched firms because of opportunity and were not unemployed prior to starting the businesses, compared with 61 percent in 2015.
But the region’s numbers declined in the index’s other indicators. The percent of adults who started businesses on a monthly basis, or new entrepreneurs, fell from 150 out of 100,000, or 0.15 percent last year, to 0.12 percent in 2016.

PG chart: Startup activity: Pittsburgh ranks last
(Click image for larger version)
Startup density — the number of firms less than one year old that employ the founder and at least one other individual — dropped from 56 out of 1,000 firms to 53 out of 1,000.
By comparison, in top-ranked Austin, the rate of new entrepreneurs was 0.60 percent, the startup density was 105.2, and nearly 80 percent of all new businesses were launched because of opportunity rather than necessity.
Taking into account all 40 markets, startup activity nationwide increased for the second year in a following steep declines after the economy collapsed in 2008-09.
“We’re really coming back from a low point and the Great Recession hangover,” said Arnobio Morelix, senior research analyst with the Kauffman Foundation. “The reason we care about new firms is that they create jobs, wealth and opportunity for entrepreneurs and the people who work for them and the people who supply them with stuff. ”
While the study showed Pittsburgh struggling with new business creation, Mr. Morelix noted the city has performed much better on other Kauffman reports such as its Main Street index that tracks the health of existing small businesses.
In that index released in December, Pittsburgh was ranked among the top 10 regions in the U.S.
“We often use ‘entrepreneurship’ as one word but it’s really a chaotic process that includes starting, running and growing a business and they are all very different,” he said.
At least one Pittsburgh-based entrepreneurship expert believes the Kauffman data doesn’t truly reflect the climate for new businesses in the region.
“We’re kind of getting a bad rap,” said Rebecca Harris, executive director of the Center for Women’s Entrepreneurship at Chatham University.
Many new businesses — including many owned by women — aren’t included in Kauffman’s study because they only employ the founder for the first year or longer, she said.
“Sole proprietorships make up a growing number of new businesses,” she said.
In 2012, the U.S. Census Bureau reported there were nearly 10 million women-owned businesses in the country and almost 90 percent had no employees other than the owner.
Also, by tracking only 40 large metro regions, the Kauffman index puts Pittsburgh at a disadvantage because it is one of the smallest markets on that list, said Ms. Harris. “It’s great to be on the list, but to be compared with New York City (ranked at 6th overall), I don’t think is a fair comparison.”
With bursts of new entrepreneurship and small business activity evident in neighborhoods including Lawrenceville, Millvale and others, she said, “I think this report ranking us so low really is counter to what we see happening in the ecosystem here.”
Joyce Gannon: jgannon@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1580.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.