There is a fine line between whether or not an hourly employee should be paid for taking periodic breaks during the work day. A federal court in Pennsylvania recently determined that it comes down to a time limit of 20 minutes.
A court decision stemming from a case in Malvern, Chester County, concluded that if hourly employees take a break lasting less than 20 minutes, employers are obligated to pay them while they are on break. However, employers do not have to pay employees for breaks that last more than 20 minutes.
“The rationale behind paying for short breaks is that the break period is principally for the benefit of the employer,” said Mike Pavlick, a partner at the K&L Gates law firm, Downtown, who specializes in labor and employment law. “There’s a recognition that short breaks help keep the employee fresh and focused.
“Also, the employee is not able to use the short breaks to their own benefit. There’s not enough time to run an errand, go to the store or eat a meal,” Mr. Pavlick said. “With a 30-minute break, the worker could get a haircut, go to a doctor’s appointment or eat lunch. But less than 20 minutes is simply a brief respite from the work they perform.”
In the court case — Perez v. American Future Systems, Inc. d/b/a Progressive Business Publications — the U.S. Department of Labor filed suit against a Pennsylvania publishing company and its principle owner under the Fair Labor Standards Act. The government claimed the employer unlawfully required nonexempt (nonmanagement) sales employees working in its call center to log off and not be paid for any break time.
The unpaid breaks included rest and bathroom breaks that lasted only a few minutes on occasion.
The employer’s policy permitted employees to take “personal breaks at any time for any reason.” The policy went on to state that such personal break time is unpaid.
The employer also required sales employees to log off its computer system (and be off the clock) unless they were on a sales call, recording the results of a call, or engaged in training, administrative or other work-related activities.
Simply stated: Any time spent not working during the work day was unpaid.
A judge in the U.S. District Court of the Eastern District granted a summary judgment in favor of the DOL, finding both the employer and its principal owner liable for unpaid wages and an equal amount in liquidated damages estimated by the DOL to be at least $1.75 million. Liquidated damages are an amount equal to the unpaid wages, which essentially doubles the penalty for employers.
The court applied the following DOL regulation to the case: “Rest periods of short duration, running from 5 minutes to about 20 minutes, are common in industry. They promote the efficiency of the employee and are customarily paid for as work time. They must be counted as hours worked. Compensatory time or rest periods may not be offset against other working time such as compensable waiting time or on-call time.”
Adam Long, a partner at the Harrisburg law firm McNees Wallace & Nurick, who practices labor and employment law, said the ruling is a win for employees.
“There are a lot of gray areas in the wage and hour laws,” he said, “but rest breaks for nonexempt [hourly wage] employees are not one of them. If employers provide rest breaks, they can’t turn around and say they won’t pay for them.”
The Fair Labor Standards Act applies to overtime compensation and minimum wage for nonexempt employees. Nonexempt employees are typically employees paid by the hour. Managers and high-level employees do not get overtime.
“This issue was an attempt by the employer to keep labor costs down,” Mr. Long said. “Overtime pay is based on compensable hours worked. Here, by not paying for the break time, the employer was trying to save money and pay less for labor costs.”
Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.